MLB The Show 26 has trophies just like every other game, but the way to acquire them isn’t what you’d think. With a total of 26 trophies in the game, MLB The Show 26 requires players to play a variety of game modes to get them, rather than just repeating the same mode.
Some require you to complete specific tasks in offline game modes, while others are tied to performance in online play. Today, I’m going to list down all MLB The Show 26 trophies and how to get them.
All MLB The Show 26 Trophies
Operation Sports App
Your ultimate companion for sports gaming. Access in-depth coverage, thoughtful discussion, and a community built around the games—and sports—you love.
Your ultimate sports gaming companion.
There are 26 trophies in the game, the final one being the Platinum Trophy, which requires all other trophies in the game. You must play Diamond Dynasty, Road to the Show, Franchise Mode, and ranked games to get them all. Here’s the list of all MLB The Show 26 trophies :
| Trophy Name | Game Mode | Unlock Requirement |
| Your Favorite Pastime | Meta | Earn all other trophies in MLB The Show 26. |
| Swing Batter Batter | General | Take your first swing in MLB The Show 26. |
| Patience is Golden | General | As a batter, draw a walk (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Are You Still There? | General | Strikeout without swinging the bat during an at-bat. |
| Can of Corn | General | Catch 5 fly balls in a single game (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Baseball is Better Together | Multiplayer | Play an online or couch co-op game. |
| This is My Home | General | Play in a user-created stadium. |
| #1 In Your Heart | Road to the Show | Get drafted as the #1 overall draft pick in the MLB Draft. |
| Going Gold | Road to the Show | Achieve “Gold” in any mini-game within Road to the Show. |
| Suit Up | Road to the Show | Equip a piece of equipment in every slot. |
| I Don’t Need It | Road to the Show | Have 50 Show Tokens in your inventory at once. |
| Moving Up the Board | Road to the Show | Choose to go to college and come out with a higher draft stock than before. |
| A Robbery! | General | Rob a home run (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Down Low… Too Slow | General | Use a swim move to avoid a tag while sliding into a base (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Defensive Run Saved | General | As a defender, throw a player out at home plate (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| THE SHOW 2-6 | General | Register a 2-6 out during a game (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| You’re Sure They Meant Me? | General | Score a run with a pinch runner that has 26 speed or lower. |
| Who’s the New Kid? | General | Get a hit against or strikeout any former MLB The Show cover athlete. |
| GOAT MODE | General | Get a hit or strikeout while playing on GOAT difficulty (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| The Start of Something | General | After entering an inning when losing, get 3 hits during that same inning (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Don’t Call it a Rally | General | After entering an inning when losing, get 5 hits during that same inning (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| Rally Cap | General | After entering an inning when losing, get 7 hits during that same inning (Excludes simulated gameplay). |
| NLB Historian ’26 | Storylines | Complete four Negro League Storylines. |
| Horses in the Pen | Franchise | Set an opening pitcher for a bullpen game. |
| Gone Questing | Diamond Quest | Successfully complete a Diamond Quest Map Run. |
| Flush | Diamond Quest | While playing Diamond Quest, buy two perks from Coach’s Cart on a single map. |
Once you earn all 25 trophies, you’ll unlock the final, platinum trophy, marking 100% completion of the game. If you’re someone like me, who hunts the platinum trophies, make sure to keep track of all the objectives you need to complete.
Published: Apr 7, 2026 04:00 pm