We’re creeping closer and closer to MLB The Show 23‘s release date. There’s been a lot of information dropping about the Negro Leagues, Diamond Dynasty, Road to the Show, Franchise and more. One of the juicer info drops was a ratings reveal for players and teams. Seeing where players stack up and who gets the coveted 99 overall rating is always a blast, and here we’ll have all the ratings updated as they’re released.
Recommended Videos
SDS utilizes the previous three seasons to determine player ratings. Keep that in mind as you peruse the list below. Additionally, each team’s overall rating among MLB teams will be listed by each respective team. During SDS’s reveal stream, some teams ranked with the same number, which indicates a “tie” at that ranking.
MLB The Show 23 Player And Team Ratings
*All ratings are offline specific and do not reflect Diamond Dynasty ratings*
American League East
New York Yankees – 5th overall
- Aaron Judge – 99 overall
- Carlos Rodòn – 93 overall
- Gerrit Cole – 89 overall
- Luis Severino – 86 overall
- Michael King – 85 overall
- Oswaldo Cabrera – 79 overall
Toronto Blue Jays – 3rd overall
- Alek Manoah – 89 overall
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – 88 overall
- Alejandro Kirk – 86 overall
- George Springer – 86 overall
- Kevin Gausman – 86 overall
Tampa Bay Rays – 15th overall
- Shane McClanahan – 93 overall
- Jason Adam
- Tyler Glasnow – 84 overall
- Wander Franco – 81 overall
- Randy Arozarena – 81 overall
Baltimore Orioles – 18th overall
- Felix Bautista – 85 overall
- Adley Rutschman – 84 overall
- Ryan Mountcastle – 81 overall
- Cedric Mullins – 81 overall
- Grayson Rodriguez – 80 overall
Boston Red Sox – 16th overall
- Chris Sale – 87 overall
- Trevor Story – 84 overall
- Rafael Devers – 84 overall
- Kenley Jansen – 83 overall
- John Schreiber – 82 overall
- Adam Duvall – 78 overall
National League East
Atlanta Braves – 1st overall
- Spencer Strider – 94 overall
- Austin Riley – 93 overall
- Ronald Acuña Jr. – 92 overall
- Max Fried – 90 overall
- Michael Harris II – 89 overall
New York Mets – 6th overall
- Justin Verlander – 98 overall
- Max Scherzer – 96 overall
- Edwin Díaz – 92 overall
- Pete Alonso – 90 overall
- Francisco Lindor – 89 overall
- Francisco Alvarez – 72 overall
Philadelphia Phillies – 8th overall
- Bryce Harper – 95 overall
- Trea Turner – 92 overall
- Aaron Nola – 91 overall
- J.T. Realmuto – 90 overall
- Zack Wheeler – 90 overall
Miami Marlins – 20th overall
- Sandy Alcantara – 90 overall
- Jazz Chisholm Jr. – 88 overall
- Jean Segura – 81 overall
- Trevor Rogers – 78 overall
- Nick Fortes – 77 overall
Washington Nationals – 30th overall
- Joey Meneses – 84 overall
- Stephen Strasburg – 82 overall
- Lane Thomas – 74 overall
- Elijah Green – 72 overall
- Jeimer Candelario – 71 overall
- CJ Abrams – 67 overall
American League Central
Cleveland Guardians – 10th overall
- Jose Ramirez – 94 overall
- Emmanuel Clase – 93 overall
- Shane Bieber – 89 overall
- Andres Gimenez – 86 overall
- Triston McKenzie – 82 overall
Chicago White Sox – 20th overall
- Dylan Cease – 89 overall
- Liam Hendriks – 84 overall
- Luis Robert Jr. – 82 overall
- Lance Lynn – 82 overall
- Michael Kopech – 81 overall
- Lucas Giolito – 76 overall
Minnesota Twins – 13th overall
- Byron Buxton – 93 overall
- Carlos Correa – 89 overall
- Jhoan Duran – 83 overall
- Joe Ryan – 83 overall
- Pablo Lopez – 81 overall
Detroit Tigers – ???
- Tarik Skubal – 84 overall
- Michael Lorenzen – 79 overall
- Spencer Turnbull – 79 overall
- Jonathan Schoop – 77 overall
- Eric Haase – 77 overall
- Javier Baez – 75 overall
- Matt Vierling – 67 overall
Kansas City Royals – 24th overall
- Salvador Perez – 83 overall
- Bobby Witt Jr. – 79 overall
- Brady Singer – 79 overall
- Scott Barlow – 78 overall
- Vinnie Pasquantino – 76 overall
- M.J. Melendez – 73 overall
National League Central
St. Louis Cardinals – 9th overall
- Paul Goldschmidt – 99 overall
- Nolan Arenado – 96 overall
- Ryan Helsley – 89 overall
- Tommy Edman – 84 overall
- Willson Contreras – 83 overall
- Dylan Carlson – 75 overall
Milwaukee Brewers – 17th overall
- Corbin Burnes – 95 overall
- Brandon Woodruff – 88 overall
- Freddy Peralta – 86 overall
- Devin Williams – 85 overall
- Willy Adames – 84 overall
- Garrett Mitchell – 71 overall
Chicago Cubs – 21st overall
- Dansby Swanson – 88 overall
- Nico Hoerner – 82 overall
- Marcus Stroman – 80 overall
- Jameson Taillon – 79 overall
- Patrick Wisdom – 77 overall
- Christopher Morel – 76 overall
- Cody Bellinger – 73 overall
Cincinnati Reds – ???
- Tyler Stephenson – 81 overall
- Hunter Greene – 80 overall
- Joey Votto – 79 overall
- Nick Lodolo – 79 overall
- Wil Myers – 77 overall
- Elly De La Cruz – 70 overall
Pittsburgh Pirates – 26th overall
- Bryan Reynolds – 84 overall
- David Bednar – 81 overall
- Andrew McCutchen – 79 overall
- Oneil Cruz – 79 overall
- Ke’Bryan Hayes – 77 overall
American League West
Houston Astros – 2nd overall
- Yordan Alvarez – 94 overall
- Jose Altuve – 93 overall
- Kyle Tucker – 90 overall
- Framber Valdez – 87 overall
- Ryan Pressley – 85 overall
- Alex Bregman – 84 overall
- Jeremy Pena – 83 overall
Seattle Mariners – 11th overall
- Julio Rodriguez – 89 overall
- Teoscar Hernandez – 88 overall
- Luis Castillo – 88 overall
- Andres Munoz – 86 overall
- A.J. Pollock – 82 overall
- Logan Gilbert – 81 overall
- Cal Raleigh – 80 overall
Los Angeles Angels – 11th overall
- Shohei Ohtani – 99 overall
- Mike Trout – 99 overall
- Hunter Renfroe – 86 overall
- Tyler Anderson – 83 overall
- Brandon Drury – 82 overall
- Taylor Ward – 82 overall
- Brett Phillips – 70 overall
Texas Rangers – 14th overall
- Jacob deGrom – 99 overall
- Marcus Semien – 87 overall
- Nathaniel Lowe – 85 overall
- Corey Seager – 85 overall
- Adolis Garcia – 84 overall
Oakland Athletics – 29th overall
- Seth Brown – 78 overall
- Aledmys Diaz – 77 overall
- Ramon Laureano – 75 overall
- Zach Jackson – 75 overall
- Jace Peterson – 74 overall
- Conner Capel – 70 overall
National League West
Los Angeles Dodgers – 4th overall
- Mookie Betts – 96 overall
- Clayton Kershaw – 91 overall
- Evan Phillips – 90 overall
- Freddie Freeman – 88 overall
- Will Smith – 88 overall
- Julio Urias – 88 overall
San Diego Padres – 7th overall
- Manny Machado – 95 overall
- Juan Soto – 89 overall
- Joe Musgrove – 86 overall
- Yu Darvish – 86 overall
- Xander Bogaerts – 86 overall
- Trent Grisham – 74 overall
San Francisco Giants – 23rd overall
- Logan Webb – 83 overall
- Mitch Haniger – 83 overall
- Camilo Doval – 79 overall
- Alex Wood – 77 overall
- Brandon Crawford – 77 overall
Arizona Diamondbacks – 22nd overall
- Zac Gallen – 89 overall
- Christian Walker – 83 overall
- Merrill Kelly – 79 overall
- Evan Longoria – 77 overall
- Jake McCarthy – 76 overall
- Druw Jones – 69 overall
Colorado Rockies – 28th overall
- C.J. Cron – 85 overall
- Daniel Bard – 81 overall
- Brendan Rodgers – 78 overall
- Ryan McMahon – 77 overall
- Kris Bryant – 76 overall
- Nolan Jones – 66 overall
