One of the most exciting elements of every MLB The Show release is the new slate of legends added each year. With MLB’s rich history of superstar players supplemented by era-dominant All-Stars and role-playing favorites, each new legend class brings freshness and variety. We’ll keep a running tab on all legends in MLB The Show 23 for quick reference and update the list with each reveal.
Until the final game comes out, we won’t have complete confirmation on returning legends. For now, we’ll highlight the new additions and finalize the list once all (new and old) legends have been confirmed. Included below will also be the full legend list from MLB The Show 22 (most of these players should return in ’23). We tend to lose a few legends each year, so this will be a dynamic post with updates as they’re confirmed.
All Legends In MLB The Show 23 Listed
New Legends In MLB The Show 23
- Derek Jeter
- Hilton Smith
- Martín Dihigo
- Rube Foster
- Buck O’Neil
- Hank Thompson
- Satchel Paige
- John Donaldson
- Ian Kinsler
- Mike Lowell
- Greg Vaughn
- Carlos Pena
- Jake Peavy
- Matt Cain
- David Wright
- Chili Davis
- Sammy Sosa
- Mark McGwire
- Ryan Braun
- Kyle Seager
- Alex Gordon
- Raul Ibanez
- Mark Mulder
- Ryan Ludwick
MLB The Show 22 Legend List
- George Brett
- Chipper Jones
- Shawn Green
- Minnie Minoso
- Roy Oswalt
- Jackie Robinson
- Bret Saberhagen
- Grady Sizemore
- Jim Thome
- Larry Walker
- Honus Wagner
- Frank Thomas
- Alfonso Soriano
- John Smoltz
- Ozzie Smith
- Gary Sheffield
- Tom Seaver
- Mike Schmidt
- Nolan Ryan
- Jimmy Rollins
- Jorge Posada
- Juan Pierre
- Mike Piazza
- Phil Niekro
- Stan Musial
- Don Mattingly
- Pedro Martinez
- Juan Marichal
- Kenny Lofton
- Harmon Killebrew
- Trevor Hoffman
- Orel Hershiser
- Vladimir Guerrero Sr.
- Bob Gibson
- Lou Gehrig
- Jimmie Foxx
- Prince Fielder
- Larry Doby
- Wade Boggs
- Johnny Bench
- Harold Baines
- Curtis Granderson
- Jered Weaver
- J.R. Richard
- David Ortiz
- Brian Wilson
- Troy Percival
- Rollie Fingers
- Mike Mussina
- Chase Utley
- Cal Ripken Jr.
- Mariano Rivera
- Kevin Youkilis
- Willie McCovey
- Robb Nen
- Mike Napoli
- Willie Mays
- Dontrelle Willis
- Fergie Jenkins
- Mickey Mantle
- Barry Larkin
- Rickey Henderson
- Tony Gwynn
- Ken Griffey Jr.
- Kirk Gibson
- Dennis Eckersley
- Ray Durham
- Rod Carew
- Hank Aaron
- Randy Johnson
- Brooks Robinson
- Babe Ruth
- Willie Stargell
- Cy Young
- Rob Dibble
- Joe Mauer
- Robin Yount
- Roberto Clemente
- Vida Blue
- Ken Griffey Sr.
- Ryan Howard
- Justin Morneau
