The football world is buzzing after a scathing critique of Russell Wilson’s Hall of Fame prospects during Amazon Prime Video’s Thursday Night Football pregame show. Analysts Tony Gonzalez and Richard Sherman didn’t hold back, with Gonzalez saying Wilson has “played himself out of a Hall of Fame” and Sherman pointing to his 22-30 record outside Seattle as proof. Their remarks have set off a heated debate, raising serious doubts about whether Wilson’s recent struggles could derail his legacy.
Wilson’s Legacy Questioned After Prime Video Critique
Wilson’s benching by the New York Giants for rookie Jaxson Dart marked a clear low point in his career. Once a nine-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion with the Seahawks, he has struggled since leaving Seattle, going 4-11 with the Broncos, 7-8 with the Steelers, and now starting 0-3 with the Giants. That decline has fueled commentary from Gonzalez and Sherman, who argue his post-Seattle woes could overshadow his earlier success.
The impact of this stretch is significant. Hall of Fame consideration often depends on an entire career trajectory, not just peak moments. While his early years looked like a lock for Canton, his later records tell a different story and have shifted the conversation.
Another part of the discussion is Wilson’s lack of big awards. He has never won an MVP, been the Offensive Player of the Year, or earned multiple All-Pro honors. Those achievements often matter when voters decide on enshrinement. His remarks on Prime Video, paired with his struggles, now add another layer to how his career will be judged.
Fans Voice Strong Opinions On His Career Path
Fans wasted no time sharing their thoughts, and many directly addressed Sherman’s remarks. One fan called it disrespectful, writing:
“It’s beyond weird to talk down on your former teammate like this. I get Russ isn’t very likable but show some class Sherm. We all know yall were the stars of the team.
Btw hawks went 10-6, 11-5, 12-4 in 2018, 2019, and 2020 after LOB was gone.”
That reaction shows how some feel Sherman’s comments crossed a line of respect.
Another fan tried to explain it differently, saying Sherman is now a media figure expected to be blunt:
“Sherman is now a media guy so he’s supposed to be objective & maybe that’s what he really thinks, but it looked like a cheap shot at a former teammate he had issues with.
I still think Russell Wilson gets in HOF.
And no one thinks Seattle had a legendary defense…LOL”
Others pointed to old wounds. “Sherman hasn’t forgiven Wilson for throwing that INT on the goal line in that Super Bowl vs. the Pats. They always say the Super Bowl losses hurt more than the wins.” That idea suggests Sherman’s opinion could still be shaped by past grudges.
Some fans looked at Wilson’s career as a whole. “If my team drafted a QB in the third round and you told me this would be his numbers the ten years with my team, I’d say we absolutely nailed that draft selection.” That comment shows there’s still plenty of respect for Wilson’s accomplishments, even if his career has been rocky in recent years.
Wilson’s career isn’t over, but talk about his legacy is heating up. His years in Seattle brought wins, leadership, and playoff runs that many teams would envy. His recent decline, along with public critiques like the one on Prime Video, now shape how people see him. Hall of Fame or not, Wilson’s name will keep fans talking for years.
Published: Sep 26, 2025 11:11 am