Home
OS Scores Explained Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD Overview
Pros
Stable Online Play; Functional Online Leaderboards; Modern Lighting Effects
Cons
Graphical Glitches; Only Seven Levels; No Local Multiplayer
Bottom Line
In trying to rebuild two action sports classics, developer Robomodo racks themselves on a rail and faceplants onto the Xbox Live Marketpla
4
out of 10
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD REVIEW

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD Review

Playing Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD is like listening to a really bad cover of a classic song.

The original lyrics are intact, though not delivered with the same force or inflection; the melodies are discernible, though many are well out-of-tune; the singer's voice and the band's instrument tones are modernized and overproduced in the worst way.

Essentially, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD is the video game equivalent of watching Miley Cyrus sing Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit."
 

Gameplay


From a technical standpoint, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD attempts to transplant original source code from the first two Tony Hawk titles into Epic Games' Unreal Engine 3.

This gives Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's gameplay a Bizarro World feel of not being a full-on remake, but not being an exact replica of the original games, either.

After putting the Dreamcast version of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 side-by-side with Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD, it feels like the new engine's physics are much floatier, with lots of weird bounces and wonky collision detection. The skating animations appear choppier and the controls in general are a lot less responsive.

Trying to play Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD with the stock Xbox 360 controller is about as futile as trying to grind a bench made of rotting, splintered wood. The button layout is an ergonomic nightmare, and trying to get Microsoft's poorly designed d-pad to read the right inputs will have you wanting to throw the controller out the window and all the way back to China.

Even when using a MadCatz Fight Pad, which features an elevated d-pad and buttons that are designed for rapid-fire, precise inputs, I was still unable to perform special moves reliably, which leads me to believe that something is just fundamentally wrong with the command input coding in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD.
 


Presentation


Having seen what the Unreal Engine 3 is capable of in games like Bioshock, Mass Effect, Gears of War, Borderlands, et al., there are zero excuses for Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's numerous graphical issues.

Screen tearing, stuttering, and framerate drops are frequent. You will commonly miss jumps and landings as a result of the framerate stuttering right before the moment of takeoff or impact.

The camera is haphazard, constantly jerking around like the invisible man holding it is having a seizure. Because the game's camera cannot properly track or keep up with your skater, you are often forced to make blind jumps and turns, which can screw up your lines.

Something is awfully wrong with Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's collision detection. I have seen my skater's body sink through floors, fly through ceilings, pass through walls, even teleport through rails.
 


Because the collision detection is so poor, crashes have the potential to occur seemingly at random, which can be infuriating when clipping is to blame for ruining a long combo.

During bails, your skater displays zero body weight and magically floats off in random directions. There are no recovery animations like in the old games where your skater would pick himself off the pavement and hop back onto his board. Now every crash causes the screen to go blank for a few seconds so the game can teleport your skater back to where he was before the crash occurred.

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD is just as much an aesthetic failure as it is a technical disaster, with ugly black outlines surrounding every in-game item and much of the game's unappealing interface. While the new lighting effects are generally good, turning Downhill Jam into a nighttime level has created some visibility issues, making it difficult to see key items, rails and ramps.

Instead of including the traditional create-a-skater feature, Xbox 360 Avatars are available across all modes of play. Unfortunately, Avatars display incorrect colors in-game and come with some proportional sizing issues.

While other modern games like Brutal Legend come with over 100 songs, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD includes a pathetic 14 songs, half of which aren't even from the original games.

The first Tony Hawk's Pro Skater soundtrack has been largely ignored, with only Goldfinger's "Superman" still in the mix. The songs cycle through randomly, with no "track skip" button in-game and no way to disable individual tracks.
 

Single Player



Goal for goal, little has changed in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD basic career mode. Players still travel the globe, completing score-based and collection-based objectives for cash. The money earned during your career is spent upgrading skater stats, unlocking new gear and additional special moves.

Unfortunately, the globe in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD has become smaller than it's ever been at any point in the series.

The original Tony Hawk's Pro Skater shipped with nine levels. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 raised the bar a notch, offering 10. Then came Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2X, which included a mammoth 20+ levels.

Somehow, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD has regressed beyond the content output of the original game, shipping with only seven levels and no level editor. It's inexcusable that decade-old games running on significantly inferior hardware can ship with more content than a 2012 release.

Memory constraints clearly aren't the issue, as at a mere 460 megabytes, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's file size is nowhere close to the 2.0 gigabytes limit Microsoft enforces for Xbox Live Arcade games.

The numbers just do not add up, that is, until you consider the fact that extra levels from Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 are already being readied as paid downloadable content. Insultingly, the revert mechanic from Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 is actually already included in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's moveset, it's just that the game doesn't continue your point combo like it should after performing a revert, as the functionality of the move has obviously been disabled in the game's code.

Activision's business plan for Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD seems to be to milk the consumer for every dollar they can get with downloadable maps while putting forth the bare minimum effort on the core game, all while having the gall to release at the premium Xbox Live Marketplace price of $15.
 


Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD attempts to make up for its lack of levels by adding three new event types: Big Head Survival, Hawkman and Projectives. None of these modes add significant value to the game, as they are just basic remixes of the same item-collecting, point-scoring formula.

Instead of having to ollie over a teleporting bum like in the Career, you now have to boneless over a teleporting bum in Projectives mode.

Or in place of collecting all the C-O-M-B-O icons without bailing for Projectives, you pick up colored tokens while following a difficult line in Hawkman.

These slight variations of objectives are pure filler, doing nothing to extend Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's limited single player value. Career mode was already a literal and figurative grind back in 1999, and it's even more monotonous now when judged by today's gaming standards.



Multiplayer


If there's any fun to be had in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD, it's with the four-player online play. Classic multiplayer modes like Graffiti and Trick Attack remain enjoyable, provided all the players are near the same skill level.

Unfortunately, there's no option to set scoring handicaps like in the old Tony Hawk games, so if one player is putting up scores that destroy everyone else's, the other players will likely get bored and quit the game.
 


Inexplicably, local multiplayer is not supported at all in Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD. This omission, along with the missing H-O-R-S-E mode, demonstrate a complete lack of understanding by the developer of what made the original Tony Hawk's Pro Skater games great.

In place of H-O-R-S-E, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD offers the terrible Big Head Survival mode. In it, each rider's head enlarges and eventually explodes if he doesn't continuously land tricks to counter the increasing growth-rate. The motto of extreme sports games is supposed to be "go big or go home," but with Big Head Survival's emphasis on stringing together short sequences of safe tricks, the mode ends up rewarding players who "go small to win it all." Players can literally just sit in a half pipe for five minutes going back and forth doing vert tricks before the growth-rate becomes too fast to survive.

With no course editor and such a limited number of levels and modes, there's just not enough lasting value to Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD's multiplayer component. Factor in the complete lack of local multiplayer, and the game fails to make itself future-proof, as there will be no way to play against others once the online population thins out.

Final Thoughts

Bad games like Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD are the very reason why the Tony Hawk series died out. The franchise's handlers have become so inept that they can't even remake the series' good games without completely screwing them up.

Apart from functional online play and online leaderboards, everything new that was added to Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD is either a waste or a technical disaster.

Instead of spending $15 on this botched update, Tony Hawk fans should grab a copy of the vastly superior Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2X for the original Xbox -- it costs a third as much ($5) and is backward-compatible with the Xbox 360.

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD should have been a nicely written love-letter to longtime fans of the brand; instead, it's a giant bird.

Visuals: Don't be fooled by the "HD" in this game's title; it's hands-down the ugliest, glitchiest version of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater to date.

Audio: Only seven songs return from the old Tony Hawk games, with "Superman" being the lone choice from the original Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. Of the seven new songs, most are annoying modern pop that sound out-of-place in what's supposed to be a fast and aggressive rock/punk soundtrack.

Control Scheme: The Xbox 360 controller simply was not meant to play Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. Directional inputs do not register consistently. The face buttons are too rounded and spread apart. The triggers, too, are extremely uncomfortable to use. Not only will this game wreck your hand, but it will also have you enraged from not being able to pull off basic moves consistently.

Learning Curve: The first two Tony Hawk's Pro Skater were already tough enough, but add an unstable framerate and awkward, unresponsive controls, and many of the objectives become unbearably difficult.

Lasting Value: Unless your idea of fun is replaying the same seven levels over and over again, you'll quickly grow bored with the lack of content in this bareboned re-release.

Score -- 4.0 (Below Average)


Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD Videos
Member Comments
# 1 THE YAMA @ 07/23/12 11:08 AM
After reading this review, most likely won't be wasting my time or money on this title.
 
# 2 mmathaifighter @ 07/23/12 02:54 PM
Terrible. I never played the originals and was hoping this would be the "essential" collection. I also read that more content would be available via DLC(not sure about this) but cant say that I'm shocked as seeing the name of the publisher. I would only be slightly less shocked if it were put out by EA.
 
# 3 Vaultboy707 @ 07/23/12 04:16 PM
I felt that this game was rather good. I didn't find the controls to be choppy at all, and enjoyed the return of my favourite levels from THPS THPS2. Although I wish they would've brought back local Multiplayer and competition rounds. The soundtrack for the most part was rubbish but I just play some Bad Religion or Sex Pistols and that pretty much fixes that (That's the beauty of the MP3 soundtrack feature of the Xbox 360). It felt refreshing to see that my Dashboard was advertising something that wasn't shoot em' up (Call of Duty Ughh) or some other random game that sucks. While the individuals should have added more material that was relevant to die hard THPS fans like myself, I feel privileged to play a healthy looking revamp of one of my all time favourite franchises. (I don't count anything after Underground 2). The graphics, at least to me, are pleasing to the eye, the mechanics are relatively smooth (I agree that they should have left the old get back on your board cinematic) and the break from the constant gunfire of modern day gaming is a blessing. I give THPS HD an 8/10
 
# 4 cujomatty @ 07/23/12 05:06 PM
I also am having fun with it.
 
# 5 Evlmnky33 @ 07/24/12 01:59 AM
I got to say i disagree with the score, Im having a blast with this game.
 
# 6 captainxCSNx @ 07/24/12 02:30 AM
This is the worst review I've ever read! Use the analog stick like a man the graphics are great for a $15 game. This isn't a full $60 retail release. The guy that wrote this clearly sucks at games, and is either the most jaded douche bag ever, or is being paid to hate on this title. People don't believe this review its total BS and is full of false critiquing of this game. Seriously the most misleading garbage I've read in a long time.
 
# 7 xrobbyh14x @ 07/24/12 08:47 AM
The review had some good points, but I don't think it's a total piece of junk. You can watch me play through it at http://www.youtube.com/letsplaysallday and see for yourself if you like. I do enjoy THPS2x better though.
 
# 8 BIGFOOT999 @ 07/24/12 11:54 AM
I don't think he was expecting it to be comparable to a $60 dollar release. I believe the point being made is that it is inferior to the backward compatable THPS 2X which can be picked up for five to ten dollars.

I have not played the full XBLA release. However, the demo did not make me want to.
 
# 9 jyoung @ 07/28/12 12:15 PM
The standards of comparison for this review were the existing Tony Hawk games that are backward-compatible the Xbox 360 as well as other $15 Xbox Live Arcade games.

When you compare the limited package that THPS HD offers to other $15 downloadable games like Trials Evolution, which features a track editor, local multiplayer, a downloadable level hub, 60+ stock levels, etc.), it's clear that THPS HD fails to offer the same amount of content as other similarly priced games on the XBLA marketplace.

Furthermore, most of the content in this game is already available on the Xbox 360 if you have a copy of THPS 2X and THPS3 for the Xbox 1. In fact, you could pickup both of those games together for less than the $15 this new HD remake is asking, and you would be getting a ton more content for your money since THPS HD is missing so many levels, modes, skaters and songs from the original games.

Add in a number of major technical issues with the framerate, screen tearing, stuttering, clipping, collision detection, physics, etc., plus a controller that simply wasn't built to handle this type of gameplay, and that is why this game scored as low as it did.

It had nothing to do with me sucking at the game.

Spoiler
 
# 10 VDusen04 @ 07/29/12 11:17 PM
I must say, while the review featured a number of legitimate gripes, I disagree with the overall tone and nearly apparent notion that Tony Hawk HD is a horrible game. I randomly discovered Tony Hawk HD after spending the previous two weeks playing through Tony Hawk 1 and 2 with my little brothers on their Nintendo 64 (yes, I understand this is 2012). All the fun we seemed to have with the 64 versions (we beat THPS2 with every character) seemed to carry over quite seamlessly to the HD 360 iteration.

For starters, we haven't experienced many issues with the controls. However, that doesn't mean we haven't experienced any issues. The primary problem we've come across is the frequent inability to make our skater turn around completely while skating in a straight line. This seems to be related to the D-Pad as you mentioned. Basically, sharp turns sometimes do not end up being as sharp as we're looking for. Past the D-Pad squaring-up issues (which can be largely rectified by using the analog for sudden reversals) we haven't had any problems with the face or shoulder buttons. Each of those setups have felt true to our 64 and PS2 Tony Hawk skating histories. Also, for whatever it's worth, we've had virtually no issues executing special tricks on demand and as we see fit.

Skaters falling into empty space is there on awkward falls that occur at unusual portions of each level (say, falling from Downhill Jam's Secret Tape area down into the water) and sometimes it occurs on regular portions of each level, but I haven't really found it to be a bother. I think as a reviewer it's a great thing to point out to prospective gamers, but I just did not feel it really negatively affected the experience. In fact, we all kind of get a kick out of those moments when they happen. I will say, we do have an issue with the brief white screen every time our skater falls. We'd much prefer the old fashion of showing the fall and the skater jumping back on (without cutting away).

With all that said, we haven't experienced any stuttering, screen tearing, or framerate drops. I'd be curious to hear what the explanation is behind that (why some folks are experiencing them, or why we aren't experiencing them). Also, aside from the "falling through floors" glitch that pops up on bails, we haven't really had any other issues with the collision detection. Well, actually, we noticed skaters will look as if they're grinding inside a certain pipe on Downhill Jam if their board is sideways. Beyond that though, we haven't had many, if any, random crashes.

Aesthetically, I am in sharp disagreement of the review. I felt every level looked wonderful and I did not even notice black outlines on items. One of my primary draws to the game itself was the ability to experience each level for how they now stand with their improved artistic updates. Everything seems so clean, detailed and full. Suddenly, the Hangar actually sort of feels like a hangar. Perhaps this aspect of the art had a bigger effect on my brothers and me because we'd literally been playing out THPS 1 and 2 in the two weeks leading up to this game's release. As such, we had fresh visuals upon which to compare the HD version and its predecessors. If I could change anything, I think I would have made the money green again. I still haven't quite figured out what I'm collecting now in that regard; I'm assuming it's credit or gift cards. Still, I certainly would not have ever considered this game's aesthetics to be a failure and I wouldn't have thought anyone else would say as such if I never came across this interview.

As a whole, I agree with the wish to include more original music. It would have been nice to hear at least one other track from the first game. However, coming into things, I just thought it was cool old songs were being used at all so really, any old track was a bonus for me. Plus, I definitely welcomed the addition of El-P and Trent Rezznor to the soundtrack. The other songs fit in quite seamlessly, providing a "new but old" feel from the game's musical angle. Again though, having recently played the original THPS's, the old music was beginning to wear on me (I was Powerman 5000'd out). This is why I'm glad when all else fails, I can play my own music during Tony Hawk HD and it actually works pretty seamlessly, complementing gameplay quite well.

I wish certain Tony Hawk staples were present in this HD download, such as create-a-skater, more levels, and local multiplayer. But to be real, I knew exactly what I was signing up for when I opted to pay $15 for this product. Had I paid $60 for Tony Hawk HD and ended up with just seven levels, my skater floating into nothingness from time to time, and the soundtrack having shrunk from the most recent TH offerings, would I have had an issue? Yeah, I may have been upset. However, my expectation for a $15 download was some updating and tinkering of old classic levels featuring new skaters that didn't look like they were once meant to be Minecraft characters and the same fun control system that made the original products so addicting. In that regard, I haven't regretted my purchase one bit. This game has been a great way to continue the fan we'd been having on the N64 versions over the past month.
 
# 11 jayenomics @ 08/15/12 02:14 PM
It's not very expensive at $15, but this game is awesome to blow through and remember the good times we all had back in the day.
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.