Home
MLB 11 The Show News Post


Check out the MLB 11 The Show 40-Man roster ratings for the National League Central. More to come.

Game: MLB 11 The ShowReader Score: 8.5/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3Votes for game: 57 - View All
MLB 11 The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 1 authentic @ 03/03/11 10:01 PM
hahaha the Cubs have 2 fake players, I love it.
 
# 2 Cubfan @ 03/04/11 12:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JustinSainn
Good, they put Angel Guzman in the game. I wasn't sure if they would since he was injured all last year and dropped from the 40-man this offseason.

Looking at em a lil closer I see no Fernando Perez or Reed Johnson, one of those two are definitely making the team as our fifth outfielder. Both had service time in MLB last year and Perez is on the real life 40-man. Not sure why they'd put fake players on there when there's a couple right there they could have used.
If one does make the team then they will be added in the next roster update.
 
# 3 Shaffer26 @ 03/04/11 07:37 AM
Reed is on the roster...
 
# 4 Shaffer26 @ 03/04/11 07:42 AM
lol it's cool. I wish Marshall was rated a little higher. He was probably our MVP last year..
 
# 5 Shaffer26 @ 03/04/11 07:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JustinSainn
We had an MVP last year? lol

I'm excited to have Woody back and hopefully Guzman. With both of them, Marshall and Marmol our bullpen should be lock down.
lol you know what I mean. Yes, if Guzman can come back with what he had in 09(Highly doubtful) we should have one of the top 5 pens.
 
# 6 Electron Blue @ 03/04/11 08:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by authentic
hahaha the Cubs have 2 fake players, I love it.
I'm only seeing one fake guy -- Aaron Luke -- who's the other you're seeing?
 
# 7 sydrogerdavid @ 03/04/11 08:42 AM
How is Steven Hill better than David Freese, Skip Schumaker, Pagnozzi, Anderson, or any other players that have had a butt load more of Major League experience than Steven Hill?
 
# 8 zippy2212 @ 03/04/11 08:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JustinSainn
Good, they put Angel Guzman in the game. I wasn't sure if they would since he was injured all last year and dropped from the 40-man this offseason.

Looking at em a lil closer I see no Fernando Perez or Reed Johnson, one of those two are definitely making the team as our fifth outfielder. Both had service time in MLB last year and Perez is on the real life 40-man. Not sure why they'd put fake players on there when there's a couple right there they could have used.
Unfortunately, Perez didn't have any MLB time last year. He played in 08 and 09. He spent all of 10 in AAA.
 
# 9 CubFan23 @ 03/04/11 01:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Electron Blue
I'm only seeing one fake guy -- Aaron Luke -- who's the other you're seeing?

Quote:
Originally Posted by authentic
hahaha the Cubs have 2 fake players, I love it.
this guy should do his homework, obviously not a Cub fan or much of a baseball fan.
 
# 10 pittsburgher86 @ 03/04/11 03:50 PM
Sorry, but, Jose Tabata should have been higher. Thats the only thing I see that I disagree with.
 
# 11 bk1369 @ 03/04/11 04:00 PM
So Esposito is rated higher than Quintero? I guess that is because of his 3 career Major League ab's with 1 K! Give me a break. This reminds me of in past games where Nolan Ryan had a slider in his arsenal. Get a clue SCEA. Why do I bother spending money on this crap every year? At least give Knight an early copy of the game so he can get started doing ACCURATE rosters.
 
# 12 authentic @ 03/04/11 04:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CubFan23
this guy should do his homework, obviously not a Cub fan or much of a baseball fan.
I'm not a Cubs fan because I didn't notice Lou Montanez at the bottom of the list who is a scrub? Get real guy
 
# 13 The Kid 24 @ 03/04/11 10:04 PM
I CAN NOT believe they have the Brewers offense rated 21st overall... There is no way in hell the Brewers can be that... They no doubt have a top 5-7 offense... Looks like Ill be doing some editing!
 
# 14 BDKiiing @ 03/04/11 11:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prince of Milwaukee 28
I CAN NOT believe they have the Brewers offense rated 21st overall... There is no way in hell the Brewers can be that... They no doubt have a top 5-7 offense... Looks like Ill be doing some editing!
Likewise with the pitching...thats what Im most worried about...13th?! they are top 6 in the league
 
# 15 The Kid 24 @ 03/05/11 07:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bdolski
Likewise with the pitching...thats what Im most worried about...13th?! they are top 6 in the league
Well looks like I will have some major editing to do then... The Brewers are better then 15th overall. I would say there at least top 7-10 overall... Don't you agree?
 
# 16 BDKiiing @ 03/05/11 08:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prince of Milwaukee 28
Well looks like I will have some major editing to do then... The Brewers are better then 15th overall. I would say there at least top 7-10 overall... Don't you agree?
Most certainly...really only Yanks, BoSox, Philly, and San Fran are IRL better, and in the show Tampa, and the Cards (with Wainwright healthy) should be better...so I would say 7th would be more like it. And how is Wainwright considered better than Carps, when Adam is one of the best in the League?
 
# 17 soxnut1018 @ 03/05/11 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bdolski
Most certainly...really only Yanks, BoSox, Philly, and San Fran are IRL better, and in the show Tampa, and the Cards (with Wainwright healthy) should be better...so I would say 7th would be more like it. And how is Wainwright considered better than Carps, when Adam is one of the best in the League?
I don't think they are better than the Tigers and the White Sox, either.
 
# 18 BDKiiing @ 03/05/11 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soxnut1018
I don't think they are better than the Tigers and the White Sox, either.
I do not think you are correct.
 
# 19 catch212 @ 03/06/11 12:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soxnut1018
I don't think they are better than the Tigers and the White Sox, either.
Sox are better Tigers are not, imo.
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.