Home
Madden NFL 11 News Post

Just wanted to post the Madden NFL 11 rookie ratings here, for easy viewing. I'll update as they happen. You can follow along LIVE at the Official Madden NFL 11 website. What are your thoughts?

#1 Rams: Sam Bradford - Overall 80
#2 Lions: Ndamukong Suh - Overall 85
#3 Buccaneers: Gerald McCoy - Overall 84
#4 Redskins: Trent Williams - Overall 79
#5 Chiefs: Eric Berry - Overall 85
#6 Seahawks: Russell Okung - Overall 82
#7 Browns: Joe Haden - Overall 79
#8 Raiders: Rolando McClain - Overall 79
#9 Bills: C.J. Spiller - Overall 79
#10 Jaguars: Tyson Alualu - Overall 69
#11 49ers: Anthony Davis - Overall 75
#12 Chargers: Ryan Mathews - Overall 77
#13 Eagles: Brandon Graham - Overall 78
#14 Seahawks: Earl Thomas - Overall 81
#15 Giants: Jason Pierre-Paul - Overall 79
#16 Titans: Derrick Morgan - Overall 79
#17 49ers: Mike Iupati - Overall 84
#18 Steelers: Maurkice Pouncey - Overall 76
#19 Falcons: Sean Weatherspoon - Overall 75
#20 Texans: Kareem Jackson - Overall 70
#21 Bengals: Jermaine Gresham - Overall 78
#22 Broncos: Demaryius Thomas - Overall 74
#23 Packers: Bryan Bulaga - Overall 78
#24 Cowboys: Dez Bryant - Overall 80
#25 Broncos: Tim Tebow - Overall 70
#26 Cardinals: Dan Williams - Overall 76
#27 Patriots: Devin McCourty - Overall 74
#28 Dolphins: Jared Odrick - Overall 76
#29 Jets: Kyle Wilson - Overall 76
#30 Lions: Jahvid Best - Overall 74
#31 Colts: Jerry Hughes - Overall 74
#32 Saints: Patrick Robinson - Overall 75

Game: Madden NFL 11Reader Score: 6/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3 / Xbox 360Votes for game: 96 - View All
Madden NFL 11 Videos
Member Comments
# 1 sniperhare @ 04/22/10 07:00 PM
They're rating everyone really high. Wish they went the NBA route and made the rookies earn 80+ OVR ratings.
 
# 2 Blkcanes @ 04/22/10 07:05 PM
What do you think of the STR rating? Suh is a 95 with with 32 combine reps, Williams is a 91 with only 23 reps, don't you think there should be a bigger difference between Suh, McCoy which also has 23 and Williams.
 
# 3 sniperhare @ 04/22/10 07:06 PM
I don't think many ratings matter, until they fix their engine you can't tell the difference.
 
# 4 fahrenheit @ 04/22/10 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sniperhare
They're rating everyone really high. Wish they went the NBA route and made the rookies earn 80+ OVR ratings.
Those are the first couple of picks, and Suh is expected to make a huge impact early so I think his rating is well deserved. That said I hope very few of the remaining picks go above 78.
 
# 5 SoxFan01605 @ 04/22/10 07:10 PM
If you think they are rated too high, watch what happens when you put in your suggestions and see the averages. Apparently, they aren't rated high in the eyes of most...lol.

I lowered several attributes on my "suggestions" and yet the averages are all showing higher than what Donny rated them as.
 
# 6 HHHBigFan @ 04/22/10 07:10 PM
According to Madden these guys should submit there name into the HOF already
 
# 7 kcarr @ 04/22/10 07:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sniperhare
They're rating everyone really high. Wish they went the NBA route and made the rookies earn 80+ OVR ratings.
Yeah but the community seems to be rating them even higher than donny is. They will probably see this and think everyone wants to go back to higher ratings. Why don't they just give everyone a 99 in every category if they aren't going to make a serious effort at properly rating players using the whole scale.
 
# 8 jbooc13 @ 04/22/10 07:13 PM
I think all the draft picks should be under 80 because none of these players have put on an nfl jersey and played for a franchise yet but their rated better than alot of people in the game already.I understans if suh rating was 80 but anyone else is a long shot
 
# 9 RedZoneD25 @ 04/22/10 07:14 PM
WAY high.
 
# 10 sniperhare @ 04/22/10 07:16 PM
Donny makes mistakes and now we're letting fans rate them? EA should just hire a team of 8-16 guys to objectively rate the NFL and rookies.
 
# 11 jbooc13 @ 04/22/10 07:16 PM
-5 on their overall an that should be their ovrl rating.wayy to high
 
# 12 SoxFan01605 @ 04/22/10 07:20 PM
Avoid Eric Berry...he'll be intercepting everything if the bulk of fans have their way.
 
# 13 Jukeman @ 04/22/10 07:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HHHBigFan
According to Madden these guys should submit there name into the HOF already
This and...
Quote:
Originally Posted by jbooc13
-5 on their overall an that should be their ovrl rating.wayy to high
That..
 
# 14 HHHBigFan @ 04/22/10 07:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jbooc13
-5 on their overall an that should be their ovrl rating.wayy to high
I completely agree
 
# 15 tyler741 @ 04/22/10 07:22 PM
These ratings are really high to me..
 
# 16 sniperhare @ 04/22/10 07:26 PM
Fans have Haden at 80.
 
# 17 kcarr @ 04/22/10 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HHHBigFan
I completely agree
I really don't think -5 across the board is even enough but then again I think that all ratings should be much more spread out to where each individual rating takes into account the full 100 point range and overall ratings would take in atleast 80% of that. Also, I do not think overall ratings should be judged on a scale that goes above 100 like they currently are. I feel that ratings should go up to 100 just because from a computing standpoint that makes more sense but I also feel that to get a 100 overall a player should need a 100 in each rating applicable to his position or atleast enough that when weighted by importance of the rating it averages out to above a 99.5. Such an overall scale would really allow differentiation of the players and then if it was truly represented on the field it would make a much better overall game.
 
# 18 kcarr @ 04/22/10 07:33 PM
mcclain is only the second pick that the fans haven't upped by atleast a point overall and correct be if I am wrong but I don't think a single individual rating has been dropped on average by the fans yet has it?
 
# 19 cdk10 @ 04/22/10 07:34 PM
I've already have a problem with the ratings.

1. Trent Williams is more athletic than Okung. How does Okung have a higher speed and acc. rating??

2. Eric Berry only a 50 tackle rating?? Mays better have the same because Berry is just as good a tackler as Mays. And Earl Thomas better have a 40 or less.

Edit: Haden with a higher block shed and tackle rating than Berry????? I'm done...
 
# 20 jbooc13 @ 04/22/10 07:35 PM
So would a 50 ovrl on a 100 scale be an avrge player?
 

« Previous123456Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.