Home
MLB 10 News Post

The Show Community has posted the top 5 second baseman in MLB '10: The Show.

Game: MLB '10: The ShowReader Score: 9/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS3Votes for game: 64 - View All
MLB '10: The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 1 keymax @ 02/22/10 03:09 PM
IMO it's shocking to see Cano and Beckham missing. And Kinsler rated so high. He should be top 10, but take a look at his home/away splits and he is woeful outside of Arlington. Kennedy imo isn't a top 10 2nd baseman. He gets on base at an average rate. That's all. His defense is rated well below average and his bat isn't something special either. So it's kind of puzzling to me..
 
# 2 etched Chaos @ 02/22/10 03:12 PM
Isn't Beckham a 3rd baseman?
 
# 3 bigfnjoe96 @ 02/22/10 03:14 PM
 
# 4 JermaineDye05 @ 02/22/10 03:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by etched Chaos
Isn't Beckham a 3rd baseman?
If we want to be technical, he's a SS. He was moved to 3B last year on account of Ramirez at SS and Josh Fields overall BAD at 3B. Now he's being moved to 2B with Teahen going to 3rd. Beckham's bat is better for a middle infield spot anways.
 
# 5 JayNY @ 02/22/10 03:16 PM
Zobrist over Cano? Did we watch the same season last year? Both are very good but look at Cano's numbers in comparison to Zobrist.
 
# 6 etched Chaos @ 02/22/10 03:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JermaineDye05
If we want to be technical, he's a SS. He was moved to 3B last year on account of Ramirez at SS and Josh Fields overall BAD at 3B. Now he's being moved to 2B with Teahen going to 3rd. Beckham's bat is better for a middle infield spot anways.
So he's a SS being moved to 2B and you want him to be ranked top 10? Until he's actually proven at 2B he doesn't deserve a top 10 ranking imo.
 
# 7 JermaineDye05 @ 02/22/10 03:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by etched Chaos
So he's a SS being moved to 2B and you want him to be ranked top 10? Until he's actually proven at 2B he doesn't deserve a top 10 ranking imo.
My main beef is that Matt Wieters was put into the top 10 without even a full season at catcher with the Orioles. Yes, he is a natural catcher anyways, but I don't see how 90+ games immediately puts him in the top 10. Beckham had a more impressive showing while playing out of position and yet he's put below Adam Kennedy? It's just odd, that's all.

However, these aren't set in stone. As I'm sure a couple months into the season the ratings will be updated and Beckham, along with other players, will be where he should be in the ratings. That could be higher, or even lower, I don't know. Right now, I simply disagree with some of the ratings. However, I won't let that change how I feel about the game. I'm still stoked for next week.
 
# 8 Flaxseed Oil @ 02/22/10 03:29 PM
Cano was also a gold-glove-caliber 2nd baseman last season.
 
# 9 Kearnzo @ 02/22/10 03:30 PM
Kinsler's stance looks great!
 
# 10 BravesBoy @ 02/22/10 03:33 PM
Adam Kennedy blows my mind, haven't had any problems with the ratings until this one. I can think of a few guys that can jump him on the list..Even my man M. Prado had basically the same numbers, but with a better avg. i hope he's not much further down on the list then...

A.Kennedy 129 gm .289 11 hr 63 rbi

M.Prado 128 gm .307 11 hr 49 rbi
 
# 11 Cuse 15 @ 02/22/10 03:36 PM
Cano will be top 5 after I get done with him
 
# 12 AInquisition @ 02/22/10 03:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flaxseed Oil
Cano was also a gold-glove-caliber 2nd baseman last season.
No, his UZR was -5.2.
 
# 13 El_MaYiMbE @ 02/22/10 03:39 PM
He did anyone notice Cano is nowhere to be found!? :sarcasm:
 
# 14 JermaineDye05 @ 02/22/10 03:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BravesBoy
Adam Kennedy blows my mind, haven't had any problems with the ratings until this one. I can think of a few guys that can jump him on the list..Even my man M. Prado had basically the same numbers, but with a better avg. i hope he's not much further down on the list then...

A.Kennedy 129 gm .289 11 hr 63 rbi

M.Prado 128 gm .307 11 hr 49 rbi
Meh, what can we do?

The good news is the game has an edit feature so we can fix it ourselves.
 
# 15 berenjena @ 02/22/10 03:41 PM
WOWWWWW... CANO?!
 
# 16 BravesBoy @ 02/22/10 03:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JermaineDye05
Meh, what can we do?

The good news is the game has an edit feature so we can fix it ourselves.
Yes, very true
 
# 17 Super Glock @ 02/22/10 03:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuse 15
Cano will be top 5 after I get done with him
Exactly that is why I don't worry to much over ratings, I can make it just how I feel it should be.
 
# 18 Super Glock @ 02/22/10 03:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsman8669
Or the fact that it's a video game.
Not MLB The Show my friend, it's the real thing havent you ever played it, lol.
 
# 19 Shakedowncapo @ 02/22/10 03:47 PM
Still haven't touched B-Phillips stance...Gonna be some pissed fans when they see this.(I forget who keeps asking for it every year)
 
# 20 Reaman @ 02/22/10 03:54 PM
Thank you for posting!
 

« Previous123456Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.