2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[msuboy11]

Quote: Originally Posted by NoFatGirlz4Me37

if David Ross aint puttin up Piazza-type numbers, STL's GM should be fired lol

I wouldn't even do that trade for piazza numbers! He said molina wasnt even injured! Unless he was hitting like Ted Williams and babe Ruth combined, I wouldn't even look at that deal!

[NoFatGirlz4Me37]

Quote: Originally Posted by msuboy11

I wouldn't even do that trade for piazza numbers! He said molina wasnt even injured! Unless he was hitting like Ted Williams and babe Ruth combined, I wouldn't even look at that deal!

you're right but im just giving a situation where it'd make at least .1% sense...have no clue what STL was tryin to do but there's the trade logic for u....not that we havent beat it to a pulp yet

[msuboy11]

Quote: Originally Posted by NoFatGirlz4Me37

you're right but im just giving a situation where it'd make at least .1% sense...have no clue what STL was tryin to do but there's the trade logic for u....not that we havent beat it to a pulp yet

Ya, I know what yo meant. If he was hitting like piazza, then you could look at a deal as stl, but would only have to send 1 prospect probably!

[survo202]

I'm playing as the Rangers and I want to add Lincicum. I was thinking of Trading Feliz for him with a couple other players. I have problems pitching with Feliz

[Totte]

Quote: Originally Posted by survo202

I'm playing as the Rangers and I want to add Lincicum. I was thinking of Trading Feliz for him with a couple other players. I have problems pitching with Feliz

I assume you want to know what some of those other players can be?

Try packaging Feliz with Profar or Olt and one of the top arms like Martin Perez

[msuboy11]

Quote: Originally Posted by Totte

I assume you want to know what some of those other players can be? Try packaging Feliz with Profar or Olt and one of the top arms like Martin Perez

Feliz, Olt, and Perez

[msuboy11]

Quote: Originally Posted by Totte

I assume you want to know what some of those other players can be? Try packaging Feliz with Profar or Olt and one of the top arms like Martin Perez

Rangers wouldn't trade Profar! They'd trade Andrus way before that!

[ACMilan99]

Quote: Originally Posted by msuboy11

Rangers wouldn't trade Profar! They'd trade Andrus way before that!

They'd have to to get Timmeh.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[TheFlyingDingos]

In my franchise looking to make a deal between the Rockies-Dodgers. The Rockies would send CarGo to the Dodgers for Kemp. Should these teams include some more players to make it "fair", and if so which players?

(Obviously I am not looking for realism as this deal would never happen....Just want it to be as fair as possible.)

Thanks.

[msuboy11]

I am the padres and I want Chris Sale. What would I have to trade? Also want Mike Trout. What would I have to trade to get these two players? At start of my franchise! None is untouchable!