Is MLB 12 The Show’s Diamond Dynasty Another Ultimate Team? Um, No...

[ripwalk]

With all due respect, it's silly how much effort is being put forth to say this is NOT another EA Ultimte Team type mode. Of course there are differences and it's not exactly a copy. I'm sure there are subtle nuances and likely many things different that make it better than those types of modes, but to act as if it doesn't borrow HEAVILY on the concepts of those modes is ridiculous.

I'm looking forward to Diamond Dynasty, but I don't think it's a BAD thing if it actually is a little bit like Ultimate Team modes... Those are good modes as well. At any rate, I'm looking forward to it.

[thaSLAB]

Quote: Originally Posted by econoodle

um lets see, baseball stats? yea thats it besides who cares how many times u see it, what does that matter? you only see th lineup card once a game, so why improve that, right? its just that its not something u see in a baseball game broadcast. knight brought it up at CD last year and they were on it but it just missed the cut. So i was surprised it was still there. dont get all show-defensive. lol next time i'll just say how golden it is.

So something like BA .000 HR 0 RBI 0 OBP .000 - like that? Yeah, because for someone who is just out of the cyber womb (just created) there are no stats, whether MLB, MiLB, college or even little league. Or would you like to throw some fake stats in for fictional 'Marvin Singletary'?

No show defense here (more like common sense defense, if anything.) LOL, and I don't know how you got that from my short post; please point that out please. It was just a serious question, that I still pose to you... what could go there then? Nothing?



Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk

[econoodle]

Quote: Originally Posted by thaSLAB

So something like BA .000 HR 0 RBI 0 OBP .000 - like that? Yeah, because for someone who is just out of the cyber womb (just created) there are no stats, whether MLB, MiLB, college or even little league. Or would you like to throw some fake stats in for fictional 'Marvin Singletary'? No show defense here (more like common sense defense, if anything.) LOL, and I don't know how you got that from my short post; please point that out please. It was just a serious question, that I still pose to you... what could go there then? Nothing? and I don't know how u got that i would have to suffer through the OSD, but yea. Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk

you put last years stats or Mil if it applies, spring training numbers.. [last years] which is what knight recommended to them last year.
these guys didnt drop from the sky

for DD players with NO history, how bout attributes, how many games he has left to play
plus its in there for all the real players in 10 and 11
you've never seen it?
come on man, please. lol

more like common sense? wow thats nice, so I am stupid? that's mature.
after that line, anything you say i don't need to hear from now on, especially behind a keyboard.

[Perfect Zero]

Quote: Originally Posted by econoodle

you put last years stats or Mil if it applies, spring training numbers.. [last years] which is what knight recommended to them last year. these guys didnt drop from the sky for DD players with NO history, how bout attributes, how many games he has left to play plus its in there for all the real players in 10 and 11 you've never seen it? come on man, please. lol more like common sense? wow thats nice, so I am stupid? that's mature. after that line, anything you say i don't need to hear from now on, especially behind a keyboard.

It's only one time that you have to see it, and it is better than having absolutely nothing. You can see the player's attributes on his cards anyways, so that knife cuts both ways. For a one time thing, it's not that big of a deal.

Besides, I don't see where he called you stupid. It's not very mature to equate being stupid with having a lack of a little common sense.

[thaSLAB]

I'm not sure how to get this across "from behind a keyboard" but my heart is dripping with sorrow, really it is. /sarcasm

And again, how you took that as me calling you stupid, is beyond me. As was thinking I was 'show defending' when asking an honest question about what you would like to see in place of that info?

Basically age, weight & height is all that is known about a created player, until they actually play. And as for what is seen in an actual broadcast, I can't say that I've ever seen a players 'attributes' listed either. I have seen and heard them mention player's physical 'attributes', especially early in the season or when they are called up or traded.

So yeah, insinuate what you will about what I just said.


Anyway, I won't stray any further off-topic, but the FACTS are (in MLB 12):

- If a player has any kind of (real life) stats MiLB or MLB, they will be displayed. I mentioned that in a previous thread.

- if a player is created (using the player creator), stats will not be displayed first at-bat, even if it's a recreation of a real person. Why? Because there is no way to add them.

- after a created player has an at-bat, they then have historical stats (albeit just 1 at-bat) and they are then displayed from that point on. No more age, weight and height.




Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk

[Skyboxer]

Played Madden card game a few times and it was meh at best. Just seeing the details of the mode and customization options in The Shows DD And I think I'll be playing it a long time.
They both have cards though......So that parts similar.

[bcruise]

Yup. They never show height/weight in real life.



Nishiokia's first MLB AB on opening day last season. Didn't really take me long to find either, just went to the rookie tracker and found players who had no games played prior to last year. Only took 2 or 3 of them to find one.

Should existing players have last year/minor league stats? Perhaps. But to say that they never show it on TV is false.

[labguy]

What does it matter how great the mode is if the online performance is so poor you can't take your team online to compete with it.

[nomo17k]

Quote: Originally Posted by labguy

What does it matter how great the mode is if the online performance is so poor you can't take your team online to compete with it.

Nobody knows how online plays this year yet.

[Pared]

Quote: Originally Posted by bcruise

Yup. They never show height/weight in real life. Nishiokia's first MLB AB on opening day last season. Didn't really take me long to find either, just went to the rookie tracker and found players who had no games played prior to last year. Only took 2 or 3 of them to find one. Should existing players have last year/minor league stats? Perhaps. But to say that they never show it on TV is false.

Well....

This was OBVIOUSLY photoshopped. Besides, he's not a DD player.