Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 6 Wide Receivers

[TWOSILK]

would have no problem seeing megatron bumped up a spot or two if he played anywhere but Detroit he would be a 96 or 97.

[themassacre771.1]

Desean>Santonio>Jennings

[Broncos86]

Miles Austin? He barely broke 1,000 yards, had 69 receptions. He was 14th in yards, 25th in receptions, tied for 21st in TDs. Soooo no, I can't put him in the top ten, let alone the top five.

[at23steelers]

Donny actually did a decent job with this one. Here is mine:

AJ: 98 overall
Fitzy: 97 overall
White: 96 overall
Wayne: 95 overall
Calvin Johnson: 95 overall
Jennings: 93 overall

[ANDROMADA 1]

Quote: Originally Posted by menglish20

DeSeasn Jackson is not top a top 10 receiver. Neither is Austin.

They are in my book.

[USCstreets]

Andre Johnson 98
Larry Fitzgerald 97
Calvin Johnson 97 - Its hard to order these three but they are head and shoulders above the rest IMO even if some might have better stats
Roddy White 94
Brandon Marshall 93 - Cant fault him for a lack of a quarterback look what he did in Denver as a mini T.O.
Reggie Wayne 91 or 92

One thing i always try and remember about reciever is the quarterback throws for so many yards regardless of efficiency that means those yards will be divided up by those recievers if you have a bad QB how can you expect to put up awesome numbers when they dont give you much to work with. You cant tell me Larry wouldntve done better than Roddy White has done in Atlanta and thats kind of the way I try to think about them.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by blklightning

^^^ i'm not downgrading him just because he had to deal with kitna for much of last season. he had over 1300 yards and 11 TDs the year prior. he's pretty awesome, i'd say. 93 would put him on that list. but maybe he's tied for 6th, and they just couldn't fit him on their top 6 list. who makes a top 6 anyway?

So based on one season, he's a top 6 player?

As far as Desean, he's the ultimate home run hitter. He's a TD waiting to happen, but he's not a Top 6 WR. He's never gonna be a volume catcher.

Now if it was top 6 most explosive WR's or Top 6 fastest WR's he's at the top of the list. But top 6 overall WR's. Just not his game.

[ANDROMADA 1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Broncos86

Miles Austin? He barely broke 1,000 yards, had 69 receptions. He was 14th in yards, 25th in receptions, tied for 21st in TDs. Soooo no, I can't put him in the top ten, let alone the top five.

One word. Kitna. Breaking 1,000 yards with all the team went through last year is in itself amazing. He will be right back to playing at an elite level with the return of Romo.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

I don't personally think Jennings = Calvin, but I care more about the individual ratings than overall anyway.

[bingo911]

Desean Jackson is definitely not a top 5 receiver. He's just a glorified kick returner.

Miles Austin is definitle not a top 10 guy. Just another homer statement. If miles Austin is a top 10 player, then so should mike Williams.