With CPU ROSTER CONTROL OFF...you are leaving the decisions up to the CPU, so I don't know what you mean messed up. If you're asking if they can get a little funky?....ehh...a little but it's mainly because the attributes are a little off if you ask me. Just another reason to edit them.
For instance...if something happens on the Mets and Damion Easley finds his way into the lineup you will see him batting fourth against LHP. Go in and lower his power attribute to what it really should be(he hit 10 homers)...and you won't see him there again.
Just FYI
M.K.
Knight165