**MLB 08: The Show (All versions) Bugs/Glitches Thread**

[bsb13]

Every time I think of Robin Ventura I cant help but picture in my mind the time Nolan Ryan had him in a head lock pounding away.

[huggerorange73]

Quote: Originally Posted by bsb13

Every time I think of Robin Ventura I cant help but picture in my mind the time Nolan Ryan had him in a head lock pounding away.

That was funny.........Robin was Mr. Grand Slam for the White Sox

[SoxChamp]

Quote: Originally Posted by maverick3176

This has been addressed...its not a bug...its more of a Robin Ventura in 1999. Go look up walkoff homer on Wikipedia they can explain it a bit

It's most certainly a bug. When the batter crosses home plate, it counts. The ONLY time they do not count ALL runners on a walk-off HR is if they don't make it all the way around, such as when the team mobbed Ventura. But since there is no mobbing in the game, then it's quite obviously a bug.

[SoxChamp]

Quote: Originally Posted by HustlinOwl

Has anyone checked if this was a rule change this year?

No, the rule was not changed. It's a bug.

[JT30]

Quote: Originally Posted by SoxChamp

It's most certainly a bug. When the batter crosses home plate, it counts. The ONLY time they do not count ALL runners on a walk-off HR is if they don't make it all the way around, such as when the team mobbed Ventura. But since there is no mobbing in the game, then it's quite obviously a bug.

Right... and if the guy who hit the walk off HR never crossed home plate, he would only be credited with a single.

[Rob_NYY]

Quote: Originally Posted by maverick3176

This has been addressed...its not a bug...its more of a Robin Ventura in 1999. Go look up walkoff homer on Wikipedia they can explain it a bit

Can you stop with this crusade already? You are totally wrong. 100% wrong. This is a bug in the game, and it needs to be fixed.

All the runs count on walkoff HR's, period. End of story, that has been the rule since Babe Ruth was playing.

The ONLY reason Robin Ventura's Grand Slam went down as a single was because his teammates ran out onto the field and mobbed him before he had a chance to go around the bases. He never made it to 2B, so it went down as a single and only the one run counted.

[JT30]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rob_NYY

Can you stop saying this crusade already? You are totally wrong. 100% wrong. This is a bug in the game, and it needs to be fixed. All the runs count on walkoff HR's, period. End of story, that has been the rule since Babe Ruth was playing. The ONLY reason Robin Ventura's Grand Slam went down as a single was because his teammates ran out onto the field and mobbed him before he had a chance to go around the bases. He never made it to 2B, so it went down as a single and only the one run counted.

Yes exactly... not sure what Maverick was getting at..

[Knight165]

Wow...that one would BLOW...big time.
Let's hope they can address this...QUICKLY.
If it's not an isolated incident(but being in the demo make me have big time doubts on that)....How the heck do they let that get through?

M.K.
Knight165

[Bat9th]

Quote: Originally Posted by Knight165

Wow...that one would BLOW...big time. Let's hope they can address this...QUICKLY. If it's not an isolated incident(but being in the demo make me have big time doubts on that)....How the heck do they let that get through? M.K. Knight165

No kidding.. man that sucks. Does this happen every time in that situation? Or just sometimes? Anyone know yet?

[jcern23]

To me it just doesnt make sense people that work on a game all year that was already near perfect in the previous version and they say they test for bugs and shoot for 100 percent realism. Your tellin me they never had a test game with a walkoff homer and that wouldnt throw up a red flag. I dont get it at all. From EA i would expect it cuz their good at downgrading previous versions, but these guys seem to work too hard on their product. Still praying its not true.