Hall Of Fame: Yes Or No?

econoodle · 10-20-2009, 09:26 PM

I thought this would be a fun thread idea.
Lets see.

I'll throw out a person who could possibly enter the hall one day, then someone answers, throw in 2 cents or so, then we throw out another. Theres quite a few out there, it should be a fun thing to return to during the offseason.

I'll start it off with.....

Jorge Posada.

Heres a link to his career/postseason numbers.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/pl...osadjo01.shtml

My take: No. I think hes a Yankee classic for sure, but even with the world series wins and a solid career, he'd have to play another 4 years or so and win another WS to even be considered. The numbers just aren't there.

I know this wasn't was stroke your chin player choice to kick off the thread, but the more interesting thought is we the yankees retire his number?.

Yankee catcher legends?
Bill Dickey, Yogi, Butch Wynegar?? Is he up there with them or is he a product of the team he played on and stayed with?

yankeesgiants · 10-21-2009, 02:38 PM

Monument Park: Yes
Cooperstown: No

Mr. Franchise · 10-21-2009, 04:26 PM

Damn. I thought he would have more hits than that. Oh well.

SPTO · 10-21-2009, 05:14 PM

If he's the #1 catcher for two more years and puts up respectable numbers that puts him close to 2000 hits and completes that milestone at DH then yes he'll get in the HOF eventually probably around the last year of eligibility. He will get in not necessarily for his hitting but for his defense and working with pitchers.

He'll have a plaque in Monument Park for sure though.

DrJones · 10-21-2009, 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SPTO


	If he's the #1 catcher for two more years and puts up respectable numbers that puts him close to 2000 hits and completes that milestone at DH then yes he'll get in the HOF eventually probably around the last year of eligibility. He will get in not necessarily for his hitting but for his defense and working with pitchers. He'll have a plaque in Monument Park for sure though.

Posada has never been particularly renowned for his defence or game-calling. If he gets in, it'll absolutely be for his hitting (and his association with the Yankees of this era). I'm pretty sure he'll make the HOF somewhere down the road. BTW, are we talking about WILL he or SHOULD he in this thread?

SPTO · 10-21-2009, 05:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrJones


	Posada has never been particularly renowned for his defence or game-calling. If he gets in, it'll absolutely be for his hitting (and his association with the Yankees of this era). I'm pretty sure he'll make the HOF somewhere down the road. BTW, are we talking about WILL he or SHOULD he in this thread?

Well in the last few years i've heard many baseball people give Posada props for his handling of the pitching staff. It may just be hot air but I put it out there in any case.

I agree with you that if he DOES get in it'll mainly because of his status as a Yankees legend.

econoodle · 10-21-2009, 06:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrJones


	Posada has never been particularly renowned for his defence or game-calling. If he gets in, it'll absolutely be for his hitting (and his association with the Yankees of this era). I'm pretty sure he'll make the HOF somewhere down the road. BTW, are we talking about WILL he or SHOULD he in this thread?

good point on the will he, should he.

I say, will he?
only if he contiunes solidly for the next 3-4 years.
Should he? then, yes.

Tomahawk · 10-24-2009, 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by econoodle


	Yankee catcher legends? Bill Dickey, Yogi, *Butch Wynegar*?? Is he up there with them or is he a product of the team he played on and stayed with?

Butch Wynegar??? WTH??? Butch Wynegar over Thurman Munson and Elston Howard???

jetercanoturn2 · 10-24-2009, 10:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tomahawk


	Butch Wynegar??? WTH??? Butch Wynegar over Thurman Munson and Elston Howard???

Lol good question. I've never even heard of Wynegar. However I do believe when it's said and done Posada earns his trip to the Hall. Good catcher all around, great hitting catcher, more rings then a jewelry store. Of course it will take a few more good years, But eventually he will get in. Make room for Hip Hip Jorge behind the other greats: Dickey, Berra, Munson, Howard, and now Posada. notice: no mention of Wynegar.

Dislimb · 10-25-2009, 02:12 AM

We went through this two years ago:

Jorge Posada a HOFer?

10-20-2009, 09:26 PM	#1 (permalink)
econoodle MVP OVR: 28 Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Queens Posts: 1,236	Hall Of Fame: Yes Or No? I thought this would be a fun thread idea. Lets see. I'll throw out a person who could possibly enter the hall one day, then someone answers, throw in 2 cents or so, then we throw out another. Theres quite a few out there, it should be a fun thing to return to during the offseason. I'll start it off with..... Jorge Posada. Heres a link to his career/postseason numbers. http://www.baseball-reference.com/pl...osadjo01.shtml My take: No. I think hes a Yankee classic for sure, but even with the world series wins and a solid career, he'd have to play another 4 years or so and win another WS to even be considered. The numbers just aren't there. I know this wasn't was stroke your chin player choice to kick off the thread, but the more interesting thought is we the yankees retire his number?. Yankee catcher legends? Bill Dickey, Yogi, Butch Wynegar?? Is he up there with them or is he a product of the team he played on and stayed with? __________________ My Eco OS Blog: Latest Entry - Top 10 Features I Don't Want To See In Live 11

10-21-2009, 02:38 PM	#2 (permalink)
yankeesgiants Drink like a Champion OVR: 11 Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: 42nd parallel north Posts: 656	Re: Hall Of Fame: Yes Or No? Monument Park: Yes Cooperstown: No __________________ The Champ is here..........

10-21-2009, 05:14 PM	#4 (permalink)
SPTO We need Cowher Power OVR: 57 Join Date: Feb 2003 Location: The 905 Posts: 43,811	Re: Hall Of Fame: Yes Or No? If he's the #1 catcher for two more years and puts up respectable numbers that puts him close to 2000 hits and completes that milestone at DH then yes he'll get in the HOF eventually probably around the last year of eligibility. He will get in not necessarily for his hitting but for his defense and working with pitchers. He'll have a plaque in Monument Park for sure though. __________________ Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club "We all gonna die...Living like we bulletproof" - Raheem DeVaughn May you live in interesting times - Old Chinese Proverb

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode