OS Debate: Real Time Physics or Authentic True to Life Presentation?

[dmslapped]

depends on what sport, if its something physical with lots of contact id have to go with Physics all the way, but if its something less physical with very little or no contact at all id say presentation as it would not need the physics, if its football (which is pretty much what this is referring to) id say physics

[saan356]

RTP is more important.

[tril]

doesnt matter, if the game play isnt solid

[jfsolo]

RTP in a walk. Presentation could never keep me playing a sports game for more than a day, let alone weeks, and months. NCAA Basketball 10 went super heavy on presentation over gameplay, and that got them a one way ticket to Cancelationville.

[Sheen_O_Mack]

RTP hands down.

RTP will increase the re-playabilty of a game, if I go into a season and play all 16 games and the hits/throws/catches/swats pileups or lack thereof are the same few animations all the time I (as well as a whole lot of others) will get bored and get bored quickly, RTP changes that with a wide variety of different things that can happen on every play of every game.

That being said RTP could potentially make a game very good, TTL Presentation makes a game cool to see a few times but both implemented properly could make a game great.

[loloben]

RTP. RTP is more important for football, however, for most other sports I'd choose presentation over RTP.

[xTriiipZx]

I don't care how awesome the presentation is if it feels like I'm playing an arcade game.

Gameplay first... presentation second.

Both are extremely important though.

[SHORTEXAS]

I THINK IT SHOULD BE BOTH

[sydrogerdavid]

Gameplay over presentation, especially in physical sports like hockey and football. I'm perfectly happy with PS2 Madden-like presentation.

[siouxredskins]

always gameplay over presentation. But you want both with the amount of tech available but only in well thought out places and not dwelled on.

NCAA 13 demo= I was tapping X to get through the score updates immediately. They just get in the way of my game