honestly thats a pretty dumb reason not to buy. Stats have been pretty good for me, so i dont think it happens to everyone. In my 2 (almost 3) seasons, the highest TDs thrown was 28, highest passing yards was just under 4000. Only unrealistic stat really is that maybe 5-10 QBs will be around 28 TDs and around 4000 passing yards, but its definetly not a game killer.
Like if I sim my games in my franchise, jamarcus/john beck actually put up reasonable numbers, but when I play with them they always suck-and this could just be me being a bad playcaller, because Ive passed it well with other playbooks and other teams