NCAA 11 Team Ratings ordered by prestige (spreadsheet I made)

[Eagles931]

Quote: Originally Posted by aws5985

I'm as big of a Buckeye homer as there is out there, but no way should our offense be rated a 97. Should be a B+ at best. The defense, most likely an A-.

Dont even tet me started with OSU. I just stared at their ratings. They seriously arent that good. (Ignore that im a PSU fan lol)

[six]

Notre Dame, Michigan, LSU 6 star programs but Miami isn't? Laughable EA laughable. If they are going to give credit to LSU for being good the last decade then why not Miami which has been dominate and on the scene for 30 years running now.

[BORN4CORN]

Great spreadsheet, thanks.

[duckfever8]

UW 89 Overall lol wut?

[Balrog]

Just because Notre Dame has had a few bad years doesn't mean that they are not a 6 star prestige school. It shouldn't fluctuate every single year. A 6 star rating means that teams that over the past 100 years have been successful. Not just within the last 10. I can't say for all of them but for the lower ranking of the 6 prestige schools are the best schools of all time.

The schools are 1-2 in wins and winning percentage in college football. Michigan is 860-282-36 with a .745 winning percentage, while Notre Dame is 821-269-42 with a .744 winning percentage.

Notre Dame has 11 national championships and you guys are telling me that they don't belong with the 6 prestige schools.

[1GATORFAN4EVA]

I know I'm a Gator fan but DAMN how did UGA get a 93 offense?

Some of these are just messed up.. But it seems there is not any super human team except for BAMA

[canes21]

Quote: Originally Posted by Balrog

Just because Notre Dame has had a few bad years doesn't mean that they are not a 6 star prestige school. It shouldn't fluctuate every single year. A 6 star rating means that teams that over the past 100 years have been successful. Not just within the last 10. I can't say for all of them but for the lower ranking of the 6 prestige schools are the best schools of all time. The schools are 1-2 in wins and winning percentage in college football. Michigan is 860-282-36 with a .745 winning percentage, while Notre Dame is 821-269-42 with a .744 winning percentage. Notre Dame has 11 national championships and you guys are telling me that they don't belong with the 6 prestige schools.

If Miami dropped to 5 after there past 5 years, then ND definitely needs to drop down to 5 at the very least. They haven't been very relevant since that last championship.

Of course I don't like ND one bit, but I think 4 or 5 stars fits them better than 6.

[1GATORFAN4EVA]

Quote: Originally Posted by Balrog

Just because Notre Dame has had a few bad years doesn't mean that they are not a 6 star prestige school. It shouldn't fluctuate every single year. A 6 star rating means that teams that over the past 100 years have been successful. Not just within the last 10. I can't say for all of them but for the lower ranking of the 6 prestige schools are the best schools of all time. The schools are 1-2 in wins and winning percentage in college football. Michigan is 860-282-36 with a .745 winning percentage, while Notre Dame is 821-269-42 with a .744 winning percentage. Notre Dame has 11 national championships and you guys are telling me that they don't belong with the 6 prestige schools.

Dude don't start lol, I hate when people bring up old A$$ championships an such. Football is so different nowadays... They should be 5* an with one really good season they move back up. Because you know what you're gonna say every year they should be a 6* because of past championships. You have to come down to earth at some point

[cjhandley]

Prestige = $$$

Texas > Notre Dame > Everyone Else

Prestige has nothing to do with being good, it's all about the fanbase. Notre Dame could never have a winning season again, and as long as Irish Catholics keep having kids, it will stay prestigious.

[foreverhorn]

I would love for some hard-core fans to sit down with their team and go over the ratings once the names are out to get a more realistic rating. Even if it's biased a little, it would be better than this...I would volunteer to do Texas and be as un-biased as possible. I would shoot for our defense to be around the 95-96 area and our offense around the 90-91 area.