NCAA 10 is better than Madden 10 Demo

[MaximumEffort]

Guys,

After playing the Madden 10 demo and NCAA 10 I think NCAA 10 is a better game. Madden looks to cartoonish for me. The only thing Madden has over NCAA is the cut scene’s (Which starts to get annoying after a while) and the graphics. Madden speed is way too slow. The QB winds up to throw the ball and you can go and have dinner before it gets to the wide receiver. The NFL game is not that slow. I think the Madden developers where focusing too much on looks instead of game play. Madden just plays the same as last year to me. The tackle animations in NCCA are way better. If the NCAA devs and just clean up a couple of things with a patch it will be hands down better.

[DirtyJerz32]

Matter of opinion. I think they are both good games (demos) but, IMO I like Madden so much more. They just have more to offer and. I like the speed a little slower. You can see things develope were you can't really do it in NCAA. I found that you're either going outside or just trying to push the pile while running inside. I feel like I'm trying to find the hole and being able to read blocks better in Madden.

But, to each his own. I'm not knocking your opinion. You like what you like.

What I can say is that this year is a good year for football games from EA.

[TrapStar215]

Look at what you said, "NCAA 10 is better than Madden 10 Demo."

[hitstreak13]

lol, imo NCAA 10 should have had the slower gameplay, just like in real life. The NFL is much faster than the college game

[TrapStar215]

^^

You must be watching D1-AA

[hitstreak13]

Quote: Originally Posted by TrapStar215

^^ You must be watching D1-AA

Not at all my my friend. Most guys who dominate college are average players at best in the NFL (Troy Williamson, Matt Jones, Eric Crouch, Tim Couch, list goes on and on). I'm not saying the college game is slow, but the NFL is much faster. You must not watch the NFL then.

[MaximumEffort]

I just think if they can fix some things and the online weather its a better game. Madden is a hype game.

[cha0ss0ldier]

First off you can change the speed in the retail version of Madden. The Demo was set on Slow.

I REALLY like NCAA this year but Madden has a lot of things over NCAA.

Cut scenes
Better Animations
Pro-tak
The slower game speed. NCAA plays WAY to fast compared to real life.
Quick jukes/actually having to plant your foot to cut
Formation subs
Refs/chain gang
It's just a more polished game overall.

Also...you're comparing it to a DEMO. One that is one month behind the retail version. Remember how bad the NCAA demo was.... Not a fair comparison.

[Alabama_Slim]

I've been going to college games all my life, but after my first NFL game I was blown away by the speed on the field. NFL is a lot faster than college hands down. that being said, college has much better atmosphere and excitement.

[TrapStar215]

Quote: Originally Posted by hitstreak13

Not at all my my friend. Most guys who dominate college are average players at best in the NFL (Troy Williamson, Matt Jones, Eric Crouch, Tim Couch, list goes on and on). I'm not saying the college game is slow, but the NFL is much faster. You must not watch the NFL then.

No buddy, I watched every Cowboys game (Bring on the hate) the past 3 years. But you can admit, the college game (depends on the teams playing) is more exciting then NFL.