Why is it a must buy? Just to say I have it? Sorry, I'm a little stronger mentally than that, especially when it comes down to spending MY money. It's people like you that inspire EA as a company to just do what THEY WANT to do every year, and not what's NEEDED. I don't believe in buying something, just so I can have a good looking shelve full of year-to-year titles.
A game is supposed to satisfy me, and once this game is mine, I should able to personalize the game so to speak. We as(paying) gamers should not be subject to whatever crap the company wants to force upon us. If I want a game that I can pass for 1,000 yds in a game I should be able to tweak sliders to do so, and the AI should compliment that. If I want 20 sacks a game, I should be able to, OR if I want to tweak it to mimmick that of real life, I should be able to. Look at College Hoops 2k8. That game plays very well right out the box, it does all teh basic stuff it SHOULD do. But if I want to make it my own game, and change the whole gameplay style of the AI, I can do it.
Sports games should be more like putty, not something that's cemented with issues that we're
forced to deal with. ie No pass rush, no defensive speed, robo QB, etc.