The Debacle. Check this out.

[NutsackII]

I've been complaining and complaining about the sim stats for NCAA. They are awful and no one even responds with answers.

Latest, since I only play a season with different teams to replicate the actual NCAA season in real life I get to see cumulative stats for entire seasons a lot.

The lates for computer controlled teams.

Jonathan Dwyer carried it like 400 plus times in a 12 game season for 2,000plus yards for 3.8 a carry and get this 0 runs over 20 yards. What a joke. The game plays awesome with my sliders but this is a killer.

[jts20]

Those look like decent stats. Who cares if he didn't have any runs over 20 yards, it didn't affect your season at all did it.

[pandoradrive]

Quote: Originally Posted by jts20

Those look like decent stats. Who cares if he didn't have any runs over 20 yards, it didn't affect your season at all did it.

Mike Kafka is considered an Above average QB, yet when I finished my season he had completed just 46% of his passes.

I also had a Dynstay with Nevada and Colin Kaepernick, who is a great QB, completed only 44% of his passes.

also I am in year 3 of my Dynast and Robert Griffen of Baylor is a 94 overall and only has completed 47% of his passes.

This is a very real problem.

[bcduggan]

Quote: Originally Posted by pandoradrive

Mike Kafka is considered an Above average QB, yet when I finished my season he had completed just 46% of his passes. I also had a Dynstay with Nevada and Colin Kaepernick, who is a great QB, completed only 44% of his passes. also I am in year 3 of my Dynast and Robert Griffen of Baylor is a 94 overall and only has completed 47% of his passes. This is a very real problem.

Robert Griffin completing 47% of passes is legit though. He plays in the Big 12.

[Barkley7]

Sim stats are awful. But since the CPU's depth chart has Dwyer at FB, he only got a couple carries a game. And the QB % is awful. I once saw Patrick Pinkey, and underrated quarterback, go 0-12 passing against North Carolina. I also notice that in 40% of the games I view, I see two different quarterbacks. Are they getting injured this much?

[bcduggan]

I have noticed if games are supersimmed there are more injuries

[jts20]

Yeah the passing is messed up but rushing stats are pretty decent.

[NutsackII]

Rushing Stats are great, if this was Madden. The elite guys in Ncaa should avg. at least 5 ypc. hell some guys have averaged
7 - 8 ypc and these guys are carrying it 40 times a game for simmed games. Again 2 -3 20 + yard runs a year are ok for the NFL, but for NCAA, you tell me Spiller is going to break one long run a year? Not a shot NCAA is about big plays.

QB % are AWFUL! and Why does Sam Bradford get 23 carries every other game? They go by ratings to much as well, Tebow, Clark, guys who actually don't throw it 50 times lead the country in most stats why Texas Tech guys complete 48 % of their passes. It isn't realistic, simmed stats should be so easy to do as well no excuses.

Other than the simmed stats, the game is good.
(Grant it presentation is still so awful compared to how they could make it.)

[Mavmoses07]

Yes stats are awful in this game. Typically rb's in college average 5ypc and really good backs can average up 8 ypc. Best averaged over 8 ypc last year which was mainly due to a lot of long runs he had. Guys like Bush and Harvin in the past average even more than that.

I thought the stats back in 08 were just right, why did they have to screw it up?

[bcduggan]

When they fixed the progression issue it affected the stats