Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

[xlatinoheatx]

I always prefer historic year teams, and playmakers is probably the best suited to do a roster like that where most i download seem to get bored after the top 20 or so players and do a hack job

[Playmakers]

Ok gentleman i want to think everyone who responded to this thread.

I knew there was some interest in old school football on these forums but i didn't expect to get 60+ voters which is great especially since most of the rosters makers and roster users are more involved with today's current players for the game.

Classic rosters are a dying breed now days mainly because the older generation players are hard to remember for the younger football fans on the forums.

Having said all of that based on the feedback (votes) recieved with in the thread this years roster file will move away from the Old Alumni Rosters.

I'm going to miss creating guys like Montana and Dorsett.......

It will be replaced this year with a File called "PLAYMAKERS 1990'S LEGENDS OF COLLEGE FOOTBALL".

What this means is instead of using a specific year only in the 90's which hinders the ability to make a deep roster file. I will select a decade worth of players who only played in the 90's at each program created.

An example of a roster and how it will break down with this new format I will use Tennesse Depth Chart

QB
Peyton Manning-(Jr)
Heath Shuler-(Sr)
Tee Martin-(Jr)

RB
Charlie Garner-(Sr)
James Stewart -(Sr)
Jay Graham-(Sr)
Travis Henry-(Jr)
Jamal Lewis-(Jr)

WR
Carl Pickens-(Sr)
Alvin Harper-(Sr)
Joey Kent-(Jr)
Peerless Price-(Jr)
Marcus Nash-(Jr)
Jermaine Copeland-(Jr)

You will have the option to Redshirt players in order to sustain roster longevity....

For example based on the Vol's roster i would RS the following players Tee Martin, Jamal Lewis, Travis Henry and Jermaine Copeland.

Most of these players I have access to several years of Madden Football Ratings and some scouting reports to provide true 40 times.

This will allow for ratings to restrict very few players from being in the 90's overall as i wll not be using EA's current method of speed and agility ratings which tends to inflate most rosters.

So what this means is even if you see a guy with 78 speed at RB that doesn't mean he can't be effective on the field.

Those of you who have used the old Alumni rosters and played with or against Emmitt Smith for example will understand what i mean. There are other ratings that can make a guy like Smith who was not a burner still be very effective and represent his style of running.

This way of doing ratings will also allow you to feel the difference in players on the field....such as throwing to a Joey Galloway compaired to Brian Stablien.

If you are a fan of the Smaller school programs and have some key players you would like on those teams feel free to post all information in this thread.

Example Southern Mississippi I'll create guys like Patrick Surtain, Derek Hoskins, Todd Pinkston and Perry Phenix.

Otherwise most of the smaller school programs will consist of generic players.

I'm really hoping that EA allows for the Option Offenses to work this year. If that happens I can do some amazing work on teams like Nebraska for that era of football.

Run Balanced Playbooks will work pretty good for teams like Michigan and Penn St from past experiences I've have with the Playbooks and Alumni Rosters.

Passing teams will like BYU will mostly utilize the One Back Offense and I don't like those teams in that era using the Spread Attacks.

[cparrish]

***Not finished***

1990's Colorado Buffaloes

• 92-25-4 record (1990 National Champions split w/ Georgia Tech)
• 18 All-Americans

Award Winners

• College Hall of Fame Alfred Williams (90)
• Heisman Trophy Rashaan Salaam (94)
• Walter Camp Award Rashaan Salaam (94)
• Doak Walker Award Rashaan Salaam (94)
• Dick Butkus Award Alfred Williams (90) Matt Russell (96)
• Jim Thorpe Award Deon Figures(92) Chris Hudson (94)

Offense *some sort of option/passing hyrbrid as they ran two completely offenses from the early 90's to the late 90's*

QB
10 Kordell Stewart 6'1 218 JR

Spoiler

3 Darian Hagan 5'10 185 SR

Spoiler

14 Koy Detmer 6'1 195 SO

Spoiler

RB
1 Eric Bieniemy 5'7 207 SR

Spoiler

19 Rashaan Salaam 6'1 224 JR

Spoiler

5 Herchell Troutman 5'7 180 SO

Spoiler

FB
22 George Heminway 6'0 230 SR

Spoiler

WR
81 Michael Westbrook 6'3 220 JR

Spoiler

83 Charles Johnson 6'0 200 SR

Spoiler

9 Mike Pritchard 5'10 188 SR

Spoiler

2 James Kidd 5'8 160 SO

Spoiler

80 Phil Savoy 6'3 200 SO

Spoiler

TE
86 Christian Fauria 6'4 250 JR

Spoiler

LT
76 Ariel Solomon 6'5 290 SR
78 Matt Lepsis 5'4 290 JR

LG
65 Chris Naeole 6'3 328 JR

C
52 Jay Leeuwenburg 6'3 294 SR
64 Bryan Stoltenberg 6'1 300 JR

RG
62 Joe Garten 6'3 290 SR
63 Brad Bedell 6'4 306 FR

RT
72 Mark VanderPoel 6'7 303 SR
68 Tom Ashworth 6'6 305 FR

[cparrish]

***Not finished***

Defense (3-4)

LE
95 Garry Howe 6'1 298 SR

NG
93 Joel Steed 6'2 300 SR

Spoiler

93 Darrius Holland 6'5 330 JR

Spoiler

99 Leonard Renfro 6'2 291 JR

Spoiler

RE
50 Tony Berti 6'6 300 SR

Spoiler

LOLB
94 Alfred Williams 6'6 260 SR

Spoiler

56 Ron Woolfork 6'3 235 JR

MLB
19 Greg Biekert 6'2 253 SR

Spoiler

34 Chad Brown 6'2 245 SR

Spoiler

52 Ted Johnson 6'4 253 JR

Spoiler

8 Hannibal Navies 6'3 247 SO

Spoiler

ROLB
96 Kanavis McGhee 6'4 257 SR

Spoiler

16 Matt Russell 6'2 245 JR

Spoiler

CB
2 Deon Figures 6'0 200 SR

Spoiler

47 Chris Hudson 5'10 199 JR

Spoiler

13 Ronnie Bradford 5'10 188 SR

Spoiler

2 Damien Wheeler 5'9 170 FR
1 Ben Kelly 5'9 185 FR

Spoiler

FS

SS
36 Ryan Sutter 6'1 203 SO

Spoiler

K

P
10 Tom Rouen 6'3 225 SR

KR
1 Ben Kelly 5'9 185 FR

[Playmakers]

cparrish,

You just saved me about 8 hours of research work on Colorado's roster.



I will definetly use that entire lineup for them and i like your suggested Class setup for each player it gives them few Soph's and Fr's on the roster.

[Gotmadskillzson]

This poll results disappoints.........I'm going to miss playing as the old guys.

[paulbrownsrevenge]

THIS IS A WORK IN PROGRESS

OHIO STATE 1990-1999

QB
7 Joe Germaine rSR 6'2'' 205 Mesa, AZ
14 Bobby Hoying SR 6'3'' 221 St. Henry, OH
4 Kirk Herbstreit
8 Stanley Jackson rSR 6'1'' 203 Paterson, NJ
RB
27 Eddie George SR 6'3'' 235 Philadelphia, PA
29 Pepe Pearson SR 5'10'' 206 Euclid, OH
5 Michael Wiley SR 6'0'' 195 Spring Valley, CA
26 Robert Smith
25 Carlos Snow
33 Joe Montgomery
FB
23 Matt Keller SR 6'0'' 238 Mason, OH
37 Nicky Sualua SR 5'11'' 260 Santa Ana, CA
39 Matt Calhoun
WR
7 Joey Galloway JR 5'11'' 200 Bellaire, OH
83 Terry Glenn JR 5'11'' 195 Columbus, OH
3 Demetrius Stanley
9 David Boston JR 6'3'' 215 Humble, TX
15 Dee Miller SR 6'1'' 200, Springfield, OH
84 Jeff Graham
17 Chris Sanders SR 6'1'' 188 Denver, CO
88 Brian Stablein
TE
85 John Lumpkin SR 6'8'' 260 Dayton, OH
80 Rickey Dudley SR 6'7'' 235 Henderson, TX
85 Cedric Saunders SR 6'3'' 240 Sarasota, FL
LT
75 Orlando Pace SR 6'7'' 325 Sandusky, OH
77 Tyson Walter SR 6'5'' 305 Bainbridge, OH
LG
56 Rob Murphy SR 6'5'' 300 Cincinnati, OH
72 Jamie Sumner
61 LeShun Daniels
C
65 Juan Porter SR 6'3'' 310 Cleveland, OH
63 Kurt Murphy SR 6'4'' 290 Columbus, OH
RG
68 Jason Winrow
77 Dave Monnot SR 6'5'' 261 Canton, OH
64 Ben Gilbert SR 6'5'' 295 Lancaster, OH
RT
78 Korey Stringer SR 6'4'' 350 Warren, OH
50 Eric Gohlstin SR 6'4'' 305 Cleveland, OH


LE
92 Matt Finkes SR 6'3'' 230 Piqua, OH
99 Alonzo Spellman
94 Rodney Bailey SR 6'3'' 306 Lakewood, OH
DT
72 Dan Wilkinson JR 6'4'' 335 Dayton, OH
79 Ryan Pickett
DT
99 Luke Fickell
70 Matt Bonhaus
68 Winfield Garnett SR 6'6'' 305 Riverdale, IL
RE
94 Mike Vrabel SR 6'4'' 261 Stow, OH
60 Brent Johnson SR 6'4'' 262 Bexley, OH
91 Jason Simmons
LOLB
58 Steve Tovar
30 Greg Bellisari SR 6'0'' 236 Boca Raton, FL
84 Craig Powell SR 6'4'' 230 Youngstown, OH
MLB
45 Andy Katzenmoyer JR 6'4'' 255 Westerville, OH
90 Lorenzo Styles SR 6'1'' 245 Farrell, PA
51 Mark Williams SR 6'3'' 242 Upper Marlboro, MD
ROLB
32 Nai'l Diggs JR 6'4'' 230 Los Angeles, CA
35 Jerry Rudzinski rSR 6'1'' 220 Centerville, OH
43 Ryan Miller Allen Park, MI
CB
20 Nate Clements SR 6'0'' 200 Shaker Heights, OH
11 Antoine Winfield SR 5'9'' 180 Akron, OH
19 Ahmed Plummer rJR 6'0'' 190 Wyoming, OH
24 Shawn Springs SR 6'0'' 204 Silver Spring, MD
46 Marlon Kerner SR 5'10'' 187
2 Ty Howard SR 5'9'' 185 Columbus, OH
FS
1 Gary Berry SR 6'0'' 195 Worthington, OH
34 Rob Kelly SR 6'2'' 200 Mount Vernon, OH
SS
13 Damon Moore rSR 5'11'' 200 Fostoria, OH
9 Tito Paul SR 6'0'' 195 Kissimmee, FL
K
23 Tim Williams
47 Dan Stultz SR 6'0'' 195 Orrville, OH
P
41 Brent Bartholomew SR 6'2'' 205 Apopka, FL

[Playmakers]

paulbrownsrevenge that roster looks good.....

I'm going to add it to the list of completed teams along with cparrish Colorado roster of the 90's.

If you have any other BIG 10 schools you want provide feel free to continue post them in here for me.

[paulbrownsrevenge]

THIS IS A WORK IN PROGRESS

MICHIGAN 1990-1999

QB
10 Tom Brady 6'5'' 213 San Mateo, CA
14 Brian Griese 6'3'' 207 Miami, FL
15 Elvis Grbac 6'5'' 230 Willoughby Hills, OH
10 Todd Collins 6'5'' 229 Walpole, MA
RB
32 Anthony Thomas 6'2'' 225 Winnfield, LA
21 Tim Biakabutuka 6'1'' 205 Quebec, CN
6 Tyrone Wheatley 6'1'' 226 Inkster, MI
12 Ricky Powers 6'0'' 220 Akron, OH
FB
36 Aaron Shea 6'5'' 251 Ottawa, IL
7 Chris Floyd 6'1'' 227 Detroit, MI
WR
21 Desmond Howard 5'9'' 176 Cleveland, OH
1 Derrick Alexander 6'2'' 190 Detroit, MI
18 Amani Toomer 6'4'' 194 Berkeley, CA
85 Marcus Knight 6'1'' 181 Sylacauga, AL
86 Tai Streets 6'4'' 190 Matteson, IL
9 Mercury Hayes 5'11'' 195 Houston, TX
2 Walter Smith 5'11'' 192 Detroit, MI
TE
88 Mark Campbell 6'6'' 253 Clawson, MI
80 Jerame Tuman 6'5'' 249 Liberal, KS
16 Jay Riemersma 6'6'' 252 Zeeland, MI
LT
79 Jeff Backus 6'6'' 298 Norcross, GA
69 Jon Runyan 6'8'' 299 Flint, MI
LG
76 Steve Hutchinson 6'5'' 296 Coral Springs, FL
68 Joe Cocozzo 6'4'' 289 Mechanicville, NY
C
51 Steve Everitt 6'5'' 275 Miami, FL
52 Rod Payne 6'4'' 285 Miami, FL
RG
73 Joe Marinaro 6'4'' 290 Andover, MD
69 Matt Elliott 6'3'' 269 Carmel, IN
RT
77 Jon Jansen 6'7'' 299 Clawson, MI
75 Greg Skrepenak 6'8'' 322 Wilkes Barre, PA

LE
81 Glen Steele 6'5'' 281 Ligonier, IN
DT
91 Josh Williams 6'3'' 279 Houston, TX
94 Jason Horn 6'5'' 277 Lafayette, IN
97 Chris Hutchinson 6'2'' 249 Houston, TX
NT
58 Rob Renes 6'1'' 288 Holland, MI
96 Will Carr 6'0'' 269 Dallas, TX
60 Buster Stanley 6'2'' 273 Youngstown, OH
RE
56 James Hall 6'3'' 257 New Orleans, LA
90 Juaquin Feazell 6'4'' 275 Ft. Valley, GA
LOLB
93 Sam Sword 6'2'' 242 Saginaw, MI
37 Erick Anderson 6'1'' 234 Glenview, IL
26 Eric Mayes 5'11'' 220 Kalamazoo, MI
MLB
20 Ian Gold 6'1'' 213 Belleville, MI
36 Steve Morrison 6'3'' 238 Birmingham, MI
ROLB
37 Jarrett Irons 6'1'' 231 The Woodlands, TX
55 Dhani Jones 6'2'' 225 Potomac, MD
CB
2 Charles Woodson 6'1'' 197 Fremont, OH
22 Ty Law 6'0'' 189 Aliquippa, PA
5 James Whitley 5'11'' 188 Norfolk, VA
7 Alfie Burch 6'2'' 192 Warren, OH
FS
20 Corwin Brown 6'2'' 185 Chicago, IL
3 Tripp Welborne 6'1'' 201 Greensboro, NC
SS
29 Marcus Ray 6'0'' 210 Columbus, OH
41 Tommy Hendricks 6'2'' 215 Houston, TX
K
19 Remy Hamilton 6'0'' 193 Boca Raton, FL
49 Jay Feely 5'10'' 206 Odessa, FL
P
25 Hayden Epstein 6'2'' 205 Cardiff, CA

[cparrish]

Basically what I did to determine what grade each player would be in is I broke the decade down into four parts with it being top heavy for Juniors and Seniors.

• 1990-1992 Senior
• 1993-1995 Junior
• 1996-1997 Sophomore
• 1998-1999 Freshman

They year the player graduated or left early for the NFL determined what grade they are on the roster.

I do not know if this will work for every school, but it worked out real well for Colorado.