Players that need to be re rated

[DaFunk4]

Baron Davis - 3pt should be lowered. In my opinon it should be a 83. He is a good 3pt shooter just jacks way to many up wich lowers his % but he should not be rated a 89.

Quentin Richardson - Guy seems to play his best with coach Antoni. Should be re looked at for ratings. Puting up 10ppg and shoting at a solid 3% and hes rated as a bum.

Trevor Ariza - Odom and with the way Ariza is playing off the bench is scary. Ariza is one of the hotest players in the NBA and is rated like a bum. Needs to be re looked at and rated.

Elton Brand - Might not be fully back from his injury maybe it will take another season, maybe hes not fiting in but this is not the same Brand we have seen. For now need to be bumped down alot.

Thaddeus Young - Future star in my opinon starting to make a name for his self in his second year. Needs atleast to be looked at and definitly needs his 3 point shoot uped.

Steve Nash - Still a top PG but showing age and ware. Should be bumped down alittle bit.

Jason Kidd - Like Nash is showing age and still good but has slowed down and D has gotten worse from age. Needs to be bumped down. Speed, and defense but dont touch steals.

Aaron Brooks - Like lightning in a bottle. I think he needs to be looked and touched up.

Yao Ming - One of the best centers but ratings need to come down alittle bit. Offensive post, Mid range, and block. He gets blocks because he is a giant not because he is big shot blocker. This is a video game and you have to factor in height. Yao would get a few blocks a game even if his block was in the 60s and not mid 80s.

Luke Ridnour - Needs to be re looked at and bumped up a tad. Is rated as a bum and is a good back up PG decent starter though Scott Skiles is a bone head and doesnt start Sessions.

Luc Mbah a Moute - He plays PF though he is special and can play and gaurd SG, SF, PF, Cs. great 2nd round gem who is gonna be a top defender and the suprise is he is playing good offense wich nobody expected. Needs to be bumped up.

Richard Jefferson - Needs love on defense. He is rated the same as Redd and Jefferson is a good defender and Redd is one of the worst defenders in the NBA.

Roger Mason - 16ppg and is playing solid for the Spurs should be re looked at.

Michael Beasley - He is 6-8 or 6-9. If your gonna make him 6-10 in the game then you need to put him on the Bulls because he would have been drafted #1 if he was accually as tall as he was listed in college.

Brandon Roy - only complaint here is his 3pt rating should be at 78 or 79.

Travis Outlaw - Same with Roy his 3pt rating should be in the low 80s not 75.

Ronnie Brewer - Shooting alot better should probly get re looked at and bumped up alittle.

John Salmons - Should be re looked at.

Spencer Hawes - Should be re looked at and leading NBA in 3pt % so should get a bump but nothing to high.

[Rashidi]

Quote: Originally Posted by DaFunk4

Luc Mbah a Moute - He plays PF though he is special and can play and gaurd SG, SF, PF, Cs. great 2nd round gem who is gonna be a top defender and the suprise is he is playing good offense wich nobody expected. Needs to be bumped up.

I'm guessing you're the Bucks fan who commented on my blog.

[DaFunk4]

Yup kinda obvious since Im a Bucks fan and we are rare. And I don't agree with you on Redd. Redd is one of the best shooters in the NBA and I cant beleive you would bump his shooting down when its not that high to begin with, but yet you give Bogut the bust a huge ratings boost. 2k has Redds offensive game done solid and if anything his D should be bumped down even though its already low.

I have had enough with crapy rosters again in NBA 2k and only reason I bought the game again bc I figured my days of spending my whole day everyday editing rosters was behind me. And then comes 2Ks clown who spends like 30 mins a week on rosters and other people who use NBA 2ks rosters and redo a handful of players and leave a ton of players left out and the roster incomplete and claim there good annoys me.

Im already wasing to much time complaining and doing roster edits now, smart thing to do would be for me to smash NBA 2k so I dont spend 40 hrs a week messing with rosters for a broken game.

[DaFunk4]

How come for your rosters you can bump up Thaddeus Young's 3pt rating because hes shooting decent from range but then you just leave all the other players like Travis Outlaw, Ronnie Brewer, Trevor Ariza, Roger Mason alone?

That adds up to incomplete roster edits. Your doing the samething as the clown at 2K except your using 99% of his roster edits and editing 1% of them and calling them your own and caliming your better.

[Rashidi]

Quote: Originally Posted by DaFunk4

Yup kinda obvious since Im a Bucks fan and we are rare. And I don't agree with you on Redd. Redd is one of the best shooters in the NBA and I cant beleive you would bump his shooting down when its not that high to begin with, but yet you give Bogut the bust a huge ratings boost. 2k has Redds offensive game done solid and if anything his D should be bumped down even though its already low.

I responded to the Redd thing on the blog, his mid-range shooting the last two years has been relatively poor.

[Rashidi]

[quote=DaFunk4;2038899260]How come for your rosters you can bump up Thaddeus Young's 3pt rating because hes shooting decent from range but then you just leave all the other players like Travis Outlaw, Ronnie Brewer, Trevor Ariza, Roger Mason alone?

Quote:

That adds up to incomplete roster edits. Your doing the samething as the clown at 2K except your using 99% of his roster edits and editing 1% of them and calling them your own and caliming your better.

Except I've edited over half of the players on teams already. Keeping up with 500 players is a bit much to ask for week to week, and judging players solely based on their performances from the first week of play would be irresponsible.

At this point I'm mostly looking for obvious changes rather than fine tuning every player. I have no idea what 3pt rating Marvin Williams is going to finish the season with, but it's safe to say it won't be a 53, hence it was raised.

It's funny that you mention Q-Rich as a player that should be improved, because he hasn't done anything since that game against the Bucks. He scored 28 points against your team and since then he has totaled 15 over his last four games! Hopefully you take that to heart and realize it's a bit early to be judging lots of players because their sample size is not great.

Here's Q's gamelog
http://www.basketball-reference.com/...qu01&year=2009

[Neon1]

[quote=Rashidi;2038899346]

Quote: Originally Posted by DaFunk4

How come for your rosters you can bump up Thaddeus Young's 3pt rating because hes shooting decent from range but then you just leave all the other players like Travis Outlaw, Ronnie Brewer, Trevor Ariza, Roger Mason alone? At this point I'm mostly looking for obvious changes rather than fine tuning every player. I have no idea what 3pt rating Marvin Williams is going to finish the season with, but it's safe to say it won't be a 53, hence it was raised.

Not to add on to dude but to be fair you should have some sort of system to know what to raise somebody like Marvin Williams rating up instead of just guessing or editing something until the overall rating gets to a number you like.

Marvin's career 3pt% is 25.2% but only averages 0.78 attempts per48 for his career. What i do for players is add the attempts p48 to the players percentage to get a rating. I do the same for mid range shots (Base rating + Jumper FG% + Attempts per 48).

I use a base of 35 (instead of the 40 the 2k had normally used i use a smaller scale for all ratings since they overate) 35 + (25.2+0.78) = a 3pt rating of 61 (or 66 in 2k ratings).

Jamal Crawford doesnt usually shoot a very high 3pt% but its mostly because hes a volume shooter, anybody can see his a better shooter than lots of guys that may have a higher percentage (with much lower attempts)

Career 34.8% averaging 9.77 attempts per48 (in D'antoni's system).
35 + (34.8 + 9.77) = 80 (or 85 in 2k ratings)

U can use career % or the guys averaged percentage over the last 3 years if somebody dramatically improved or significantly dropped off.

In effect Marvin is a 26% 3pt shooter for career. This year with his added attempts (up to 2.16) hes a true 27.4% a 62 rating .1 away from being a 63.

But i just dont like guessing. Too much bias and/or personal opinion involved not enough fact. But thats just me.

[DCAllAmerican]

Everyone needs to be edited

[stizz]

Hey Neon, do you have a 360?

[Neon1]

Quote: Originally Posted by stizz

Hey Neon, do you have a 360?

Yeah why you ask?