The Outsiders vs. Rashidi

[Tobi89]

Which roster do you think is the best? I've downloaded the outsiders and I think it is really good, but I've heard that Rashidi is just as good.

[goillini413]

anyone here will tell you that neither is 'better' than the other. It's a matter of choice. Here are the facts:

Nogster's rosters are complete, Rashidi is still not quite done editing every single player.
Nogster focuses more on tendencies while Rashidi is more about ratings.
Nogster said that he would be releasing a new roster every 2 weeks or so, Rashidi I think will do his slightly more often.
Nogster's rosters have portlandblazer doing the appearences and accessories and he does a very good job, Rashidi does them himself and he also does a fine job.

Case put: Download both and SEE WHICH ONE YOU LIKE BETTER!!!! Don't ask someone else to make a decision for you...

If you are trying to cause conflict on this board then leave!!!

[Rashidi]

Quote: Originally Posted by goillini413

If you are trying to cause conflict on this board then leave!!!

What's wrong with posing the question? It's not like there's anyone out there writing reviews on the submitted content.

[GameOver]

Quote: Originally Posted by goillini413

If you are trying to cause conflict on this board then leave!!!

i think thats all this topic shall lead to is a huge debate and then be a bash topic for some people who like one roster more then the other mods plz lock now befor that happens

and btw im sure when my 360 gets back in 18 days form microsoft ill like and use both rosters bc for 2k8 i used 4 rosters and liked them all.

[Tobi89]

Damn I asked a simple question. Some people just need to lay low anyway Rashidi do u actually change the player tendencies cuz i'm thinking about trying out ur rosters.

[Rashidi]

Quote: Originally Posted by Tobi89

Rashidi do u actually change the player tendencies

Of course.

[Bornindamecca]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rashidi

What's wrong with posing the question? It's not like there's anyone out there writing reviews on the submitted content.

It's about where the question leads. Right now there is no real criteria for judging one person's sliders against another. The discussion is totally subjective. Despite this, people will eventually turn it into dogmatic war and disagreements escalate into hyperbole. Now "fill in name's" sliders aren't just a matter of personal preference, they "suck".

Right now we have a productive, appreciative environment, which is important because sliders and ratings are volunteer work. The alternative to a baseless discussion is for people to download the rosters/sliders, try out a few games and see what they like.

Considering how much hard work is put into them, that's the least people can do. If you like the sliders/ratings, show the guy some love, if you don't, try the next set or make some yourself.


For the record, the game plays well with Rashidi's rosters and I haven't tried Nogster's, but intend to.

[bowdown2shadi]

I didn't notice much when using the REAL 2k Insider(Rashidi) ones but that was one of his earlier versions. I tried Nogsters(Outsiders) and liked them. But thats my own opinion.

[Null]

Anyone have a version of these for the PC? or a PC roster with all the missing players?

[Tobi89]

Bornindamecca I understand what ur saying but people just like to create conflicts for no reason. I just wanted to know what some of u 2K players are using as ur primary rosters.