Could this game have the best gameplay in '07?

[GoDevilsASU]

After playing MLB 2K7 (PS3)and now MVP 07, I think MVP 07 plays way better. I'm just talking about gameplay. Hopefully, MLB 07 The Show (PS3) will fix all the problems that are in PS2 - but I doubt it. If so, I'll deal with the horrible rosters in MVP 07 and lack of graphics for a baseball game that plays legit and is actually fun to play.

[Head Coach]

Have you played the show 07 yet? It blows NCAA away. They have made some real good improvements in the gameplay.

[HustlinOwl]

Easily. MVP is the only game for me. The other two games are at least 3 years behind on gameplay if they ever address that who knows

[pberardi]

Quote: Originally Posted by GoDevilsASU

After playing MLB 2K7 (PS3)and now MVP 07, I think MVP 07 plays way better. I'm just talking about gameplay. Hopefully, MLB 07 The Show (PS3) will fix all the problems that are in PS2 - but I doubt it. If so, I'll deal with the horrible rosters in MVP 07 and lack of graphics for a baseball game that plays legit and is actually fun to play.

I always stated that NCAA plays a beautiful game of baseball. Pure, no frills baseball. MLB plays a great game of baseball as well. Many of the 02' problems have been fixed and it plays great. MLB pitching engine is real and fun. MVP's although challenging becomes too easy.

MLB's hitting is a bit quirky but challenging, MVP's IMO still the best hitting engine out there.

MLB is fast pitch based while NCAA is slow. Hit variety is much improved in MLB as NCAA is great.

Both games are very good and I would love to play both. Unfortunately, timing and pitch physics makes it impossible to transfer skills day to day. I tried and I lose my timing altering games.

Really, both are great games. However, EA made the decision to go to war on franchise rights with NFL and lost the MLB. Time for a new direction for many ex-MVP players.