OS Arbitration Panel Project 2012

[bwoodring9]

If someone is doing the Red Sox, I hope it is ok if I ask this question. I'm the pirates in my franchise and they are willing to trade Xander Bogaerts for Garrett Jones. How does that sound?

[jhendricks316]

I wouldn't mind a small role with the Tigers.

[Bard]

Quote: Originally Posted by bwoodring9

If someone is doing the Red Sox, I hope it is ok if I ask this question. I'm the pirates in my franchise and they are willing to trade Xander Bogaerts for Garrett Jones. How does that sound?

Red Sox would never do that. Even with a banged up OF we are better without Jones and Bogaerts is one of our top prospects. Sorry but no way i would do that in my franchise or it happens in real life.

[HechticSooner]

As far as picking a team out of the ones I listed and to be a team player in this project I would do any of the that need someone, and if they all do I would say my no.1 choice would be KC since they aren't my homer team and thus I could be more objective with them follow by the Nats then the padres, with the Mets being last since they're my team and I night be a little bias there.

[pistolpete]

I'm glad people are pretty responsive. I'll update the first post with team reps, and if pokerplayer lays down some ground rules I'll gladly add those too.

As far as home-town bias I wouldn't really worry about that because the person who is providing feedback isn't actually making the trade.

I'll partake in the Brewers.

EDIT: This could be a dynamic thing too which might be fun. Say I find I keep getting more and more talent offered for Grienke, maybe some people down the road may have to give up more than earlier on.

[statdude]

I'm playing as the Blue jays and I want to trade Jose Bautista to the Dodgers. What would be a fair return for me using mostly mlb players?

[Dpauley23]

Quote: Originally Posted by statdude

I'm playing as the Blue jays and I want to trade Jose Bautista to the Dodgers. What would be a fair return for me using mostly mlb players?

It would probably be best if you asked this in the trade discussion thread

[statdude]

ok. thanks

[pokerplaya]

Quote: Originally Posted by bwoodring9

If someone is doing the Red Sox, I hope it is ok if I ask this question. I'm the pirates in my franchise and they are willing to trade Xander Bogaerts for Garrett Jones. How does that sound?

It is absolutely OK to start asking the representatives of the Red Sox for their opinion on how they would proceed during this negotiation. Thanks for stopping by!

[pokerplaya]

Quote: Originally Posted by pistolpete

I'm glad people are pretty responsive. I'll update the first post with team reps, and if pokerplayer lays down some ground rules I'll gladly add those too. As far as home-town bias I wouldn't really worry about that because the person who is providing feedback isn't actually making the trade. I'll partake in the Brewers. EDIT: This could be a dynamic thing too which might be fun. Say I find I keep getting more and more talent offered for Grienke, maybe some people down the road may have to give up more than earlier on.

I replied to your email, Pete and am hopeful you aren't looking at my initiative compiling the list as "stealing your thunder." I didn't get that impression from your message, but I was just trying to help, so thank you for offering to update the first page and also get involved with a team. I think you had a great idea, I just wanted to make sure it didn't fall down the page, or even worse get closed because it "wasn't different" than the trade discussion thread. Especially once we fill all slots, this will be MUCH different from the normal Trade Discussion thread...

With that said, I did say that I would be updating the list of GMs when I got home from work tonight, and while I'm a little late, here I am. I will update the previous list I'd made to be thorough for new people to the thread, and I will post a new list at the end of the thread so you know the most current.

Thanks again! And I saw you wanted to be involved with Milwaukee, so I'll be adding you now!