More Physics Issues Madden 10 vid vs NFL 2K5

[WFColonel56]

What about these vids do some of you guys not get

It is just a highlight tape to show off that division

NFC south/north/east/west
These vids are making these divisions look as good as they can

These vids are played on rookie or pro so you will have an easier time breaking tackles and doing crazy stuff........

If you were putting out a highlight tape of your self would you put a basic run for 1 yard?????? NOOOO!!!!!! You show the flashey run where you make 3 guys miss and fall flat on their faces...

This is no diff than the 1st vid they put out with ARZ and PITT.....Its just a highlight tape god

[kjcheezhead]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattIntellect

With the developers on the forums, we have a chance to get things done construcively (constructive criticism) instead of having a bunch of posts saying that EA Sucks.

This is constructive criticism. Apex didn't say EA sucks, he said the physics isn't right and showed his examples. Why is it when people point out problems it's automatically bashers and 2k5 fans wanting to spread hate? Not everyone is in love with what they see and the reason the developers supposedly post here is to find out why so they can fix it.

[Echopax]

Quote: Originally Posted by WFColonel56

What about these vids do some of you guys not get It is just a highlight tape to show off that division NFC south/north/east/west These vids are making these divisions look as good as they can These vids are played on rookie or pro so you will have an easier time breaking tackles and doing crazy stuff........ If you were putting out a highlight tape of your self would you put a basic run for 1 yard?????? NOOOO!!!!!! You show the flashey run where you make 3 guys miss and fall flat on their faces... This is no diff than the 1st vid they put out with ARZ and PITT.....Its just a highlight tape god

I like how every time someone points out a legimate flaw in the game, someone always has to go on a rant about how "it's an early build".

Yeah, sure. Players don't move any differently on rookie than they do on all-pro, they just react different with their AI.

[kmart2180]

Madden 10 is gonna rock this year There have been an insane amount of improvements from 09. I cannot wait to play this game.

But I gotta say that ps2/xbox versions had better running animations. The cuts, the way the player leans looks amazing. Too bad they couldnt copy over the code or something.

After seeing some ps2 madden video's I can only wonder why they did not port over that game and just add the graphics on top of it. It was a great game.

[parrothead]

Has the development team ever commented on Apex's videos? I'd be curious to hear their take on them. Do we know if they've ever even seen them?

[Exonerated]

Quote: Originally Posted by parrothead

Has the development team ever commented on Apex's videos? I'd be curious to hear their take on them. Do we know if they've ever even seen them?

Yes they have. Ian even quoted one of Apex's video on an Official Madden Blog.

Can't they turn around and say, 'It's not a good idea' or 'Its not in our plans this year to address this'

What more do you want from them? Have them answer every single post in every thread?

[parrothead]

No no no I dont want anything from them. I was just trying to get a little background, on this ever so lively discussion. The animations don't seem too bad to me. I don't watch the highlight vid stuff anyway, because that's not what it looks like when you play, so I don't really care. I'm sorry if I offended, I meant no harm.

[Exonerated]

Funny thing is. That highlight vid did have a couple of 1 yard runs!!!!

[Segagendude]

This should be good.....after scoring an exciting, game-winning touchdown when playing the game,people like Apex will not enjoy the moment. They'll spend the next several hours breaking down replays at every angle looking for every single fault and posting them on Youtube.....

(Instead of celebrating a major win in The Show, I should do the same........yeah, right!)

Whatever floats yer boat.

[mrprice33]

Quote: Originally Posted by Echopax

I like how every time someone points out a legimate flaw in the game, someone always has to go on a rant about how "it's an early build". Yeah, sure. Players don't move any differently on rookie than they do on all-pro, they just react different with their AI.

where did he say anything about an early build?