All Ratings Talk Here Per Millennium

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by statpacker8351

Leinart should be higher than 62

I agree that other than the fact that Leinart's head/motivation hasn't always ben there,he's done nothing to warrant a rating like that.I think he deserves mid-70's at least.

I'd have to wonder where qb's like Alex Smith,Vince Young and JaMarcus Russell are then because they shouldn't be rated any higher.

[gr18]

I will also say that if/when Favre comes back he should be rated around an 84 IMO.I have a feeling he will get rated high 80's to low 90's out of respect but Aaron Rodgers is a little better at this point and he's probably an 86 or so.

[iBlievN5]

Quote: Originally Posted by gr18

I agree that other than the fact that Leinart's head/motivation hasn't always ben there,he's done nothing to warrant a rating like that.I think he deserves mid-70's at least. I'd have to wonder where qb's like Alex Smith,Vince Young and JaMarcus Russell are then because they shouldn't be rated any higher.

maybe alex smith hasn't been better, but the other two have at least been good enough to start/win. both with subpar receiving cores, unlike mr. leinart.

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by iBlievN5

maybe alex smith hasn't been better, but the other two have at least been good enough to start/win. both with subpar receiving cores, unlike mr. leinart.

VY has at least been somewhat successful(wins but poor qb rating) but Leinart has certainly been better than Russell from the little he's played.I expect Jeff Garcia to start for the Raiders if they actually want to win a few games.

I'll agree though on the receivers part.

[cowboyscowboys]

Some early Cowboys player ratings (Real)

D.Ware 98 Ovr, 86 Spd, 83 Str, 90 Agi <--- To much agility not a DB
J.Witten 97 Ovr, 75 Spd, 73 Str, 79 Agi <--- More Spd less quick and agile
L.Davis 93 Ovr 99 Str
A.Gurode 93 Ovr 95 Str
T.Newman 93 Ovr 95 Spd, 51 Str, 97 Agi <--- Needs Higher Speed (Track Star) 97 would be right IMO
M.Barber 91 Ovr 86 Spd, 84 Str, 87Agi <--- Overrated! should be 88 tops
F.Adams 88 Ovr 97 Str
G.Ellis 88 Ovr 74 Spd, 82 Str, 74 Agi <--- Overrated! should be 83 tops
T.Romo 88 Ovr 73 Spd, 57 Str, 77 Agi

These were all that were on screen

[iBlievN5]

Quote: Originally Posted by cowboyscowboys

Some early Cowboys player ratings (Real) D.Ware 98 Ovr, 86 Spd, 83 Str, 90 Agi <--- To much agility not a DB J.Witten 97 Ovr, 75 Spd, 73 Str, 79 Agi <--- More Spd less quick and agile L.Davis 93 Ovr 99 Str A.Gurode 93 Ovr 95 Str T.Newman 93 Ovr 95 Spd, 51 Str, 97 Agi <--- Needs Higher Speed (Track Star) 97 would be right IMO M.Barber 91 Ovr 86 Spd, 84 Str, 87Agi <--- Overrated! should be 88 tops F.Adams 88 Ovr 97 Str G.Ellis 88 Ovr 74 Spd, 82 Str, 74 Agi <--- Overrated! should be 83 tops T.Romo 88 Ovr 73 Spd, 57 Str, 77 Agi These were all that were on screen

everyone under witten, excluding romo and newman, is grossly overrated.

[NOBLE]

Quote: Originally Posted by I Peench

What do you guys think about Moreno's speed? You think 86 is a good number? Keep in mind his ACC is 96.

That fits him perfectly as of right now. He's got a good explosion, but he's far from a burner.

[cowboyscowboys]

Quote: Originally Posted by iBlievN5

everyone under witten, excluding romo and newman, are grossly overrated.

Grossly is a strong term, but I can see where your coming from the way you manhandled our O-Line. Flo could go down to 86 for his lazy play last year. Gurode I love! minus his shotgun snaps and Leonard Davis well I am not his biggest fan I would say a 91 Overall. Like I said already Ellis 83 tops, Barber 88 tops lower IMO

Also McBriar our punter is a 95 lol no deduction for snapped ankles I guess.

[iBlievN5]

Quote: Originally Posted by cowboyscowboys

Grossly is a strong term, but I can see where your coming from the way you manhandled our O-Line. Flo could go down to 86 for his lazy play last year. Gurode I love! minus his shotgun snaps and Leonard Davis well I am not his biggest fan I would say a 91 Overall. Like I said already Ellis 83 tops, Barber 88 tops lower IMO Also McBriar our punter is a 95 lol no deduction for snapped ankles I guess.

i overlooked mcbriar, he's pretty epic actually. and i agree with your analysis as well.

[cowboyscowboys]

Arizona Cardinals Player ratings
L.Fitz 99 Ovr, 89 Spd, 75 Str, 93 Agi
A.Wilson 98 Ovr, 85 Spd, 75 Str, 88 Agi <-- Str 78+ and Spd 87+
D.Dockett 95 Ovr 73 Spd, 90 Str, 70 Agi
A.Boldin 94 Ovr, 89 Spd, 80 Str, 92 Agi
K.Dansby 92 Ovr, 79 Spd, 77 Str, 84 Agi <-- Spd 80+
M.Gandy 86 Ovr 92 Str
B.Berry 86 Ovr 75 Spd, 82 Str, 73 Agi
A.Rolle 86 Ovr 84 Spd, 68 Str, 93 Agi <-- Spd 87+ Agi 91-

It's gonna be a transition getting used to the gaps in speed ratings etc.

Just Realized Jay Ratliff is underrated should be 90+ in new rating system especially with Dockett being a 95 Ovr. Also Bradie James should be 86+ we will see about him.