Madden 10 Pat White = Madden 04 Mike Vick?

[jeremym480]

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mark my words:

The ONLY way Michael Vick will be successful in the NFL again is if he goes to a team and becomes that teams Kordell Stewart. He may have a decent chance at success in that type of role, IMO.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Also, he has little to no chance at success in the NFL as a QB. Given his lack of passing ability and the fact that he hasn't played in two years. Maybe he will do well in the UFL this year!!

Back on topic, I believe that preventing Madden cheese has progressed since 04 so I do not think people will be able to expliot defenses with White the way they used to with Vick.

That's just my .02 so take it for what's it worth....

[lasthour]

Vick is a great QB. Some people are convinced that whatever they think in their minds is reality. Vick is one of the greatest players to play the game and may get a chance to play again so he can remind people of why.

Now a question or 2.

Why would a player that runs a low sub 4 in the 40 dash limit himself to pocket passing?

Is not that what a slow or average speed QB should be doing so they can play more than a season or 2?

[damien6663]

Quote: Originally Posted by BLBxLakers24

Attention everybody Mick Vick sucks. Lmao I love how much ppl hate him just because he wasnt a great passes. Ok, what ever. He might not have been the best QB but he was one of the best players on the field every time he stepped out there. Vick went 110% every play. Im done arguing about if he is good or bad. its obvious from watching the man play he was a very gifted and special player. Thats why the fans loved him and the city of atlanta loved him. Some ppl are such jokes, I know any falcon fan loved him, but he makes one mistake and you hate him? Lmao at the guy saying there glad to see vick gone. YEAH OKAY! WHEN HE WAS THE FACE OF YOUR FRANCHISE! Keep living in the moment. Be a real fan and support your players threw there ups and downs. Mick Vick is one of the most talented players to ever play the game and there is no debating that.

Well even with all that talent, he still couldnt hit a school bus running a slant from 15 yards away.

Vick was talented-exciting...a great qb? hell no. He is basically the same deal as vince young, once people got over the initial highlight reel runs, they realized that the guy really can not throw well enough to be a true top tier quarterback.

Roddy White and Michael Jenkins were considered to be busts during the vick era, when now that they have matty ice, they have proven to be very good football players.

Talent does not equal greatness. Vince Young, Reggie Bush, Charles Rogers, all have talent, and it is undeniable...are they great football players? didn't think so.

[Qb]

Quote: Originally Posted by jeremym480

Back on topic, I believe that preventing Madden cheese has progressed since 04 so I do not think people will be able to expliot defenses with White the way they used to with Vick.

This was the only part of the posts after my warning that even attempted to address the topic. Guess I'll just close the thread since it appears it will only continue down the same path...