Playmakers Madden 12 All Time Team Rosters

[juicer420]

If anyone is interested on doing these for the PS3, i started a thread and I'm starting to crank them out. I got a lot of the NFC west done. I haven't seen anything else start a PS3 version so I'm going for it. I'm not touching ratings for now until I get closer to finishing all the editing and CAPs. This way we can kind of get all the ratings to coincide together. Hoping to make it a community project. Check it out.

[spit_bubble]

Quote: Originally Posted by juicer420

If anyone is interested on doing these for the PS3, i started a thread and I'm starting to crank them out. I got a lot of the NFC west done. I haven't seen anything else start a PS3 version so I'm going for it. I'm not touching ratings for now until I get closer to finishing all the editing and CAPs. This way we can kind of get all the ratings to coincide together. Hoping to make it a community project. Check it out.

That's cool that you've started one for the PS3.

Forget what I said a few posts ago about possibly creating a PS3 version. I've been creating a handful of players, and while it's relatively easy, I'm starting to realize there's just no way I'd have the time to do anything significant.

[Playmakers]

Here's what's going on

For the XBOX 360 i'm trying to decide to how to pass the file back and forth between me and another USER who has offered to help me out.

Once i get that straighten out then i will start the file...it might just be a situation where i simply just handle everything myself if that doesn't work which is no biggie because I've done much larger roster files than this would be all alone.

I think someone is doing a PS3 version so you guys are covered on that end now....

I read in his thread about duplicate players existing....just so that we are on the same page.

THERE WILL BE NO DUPLICATE PLAYERS ON THIS FILE....

I don't like that method as I prefer one guy slotted to one team only....these will All-Time rosters which means I' not creating teams based on a season or year.

This is like my NCAA Alumni Rosters where i take some of the best players in team history and put them all on one team and let you decide who to start and who will be the backups.

These will all be great players but lets get one thing clear they won't all be 90+ overall rated players....if a guy wasn't listed as a burner i'm not going to make him a burner just to inflate his overall rating.

I'm not rating guys based on overall's I'm not rating guys base don a overall rating....I'm rating guys based on Tendencies

So if i guy didn't have great speed but he had great hands and was terrific route runner and playmaker I.E. Jerry Rice if his speed keeps him from being a 99 overall then so be it. His tendency ratings will allow him to do hi job and be Jerry Rice....the same thing applies to Emmitt Smith he'll be productive without being rated a 90+ speed

Ifyour looking for all of your favorite players to be speed demons this fiel won't be for you.....if your looking for guys to be rated 90+ overall because they were great then this file won't be for you.....

There are several resources that i can use to determine the 25 best players in NFL history....those guys are the one's you'll most likely see rated in the 90's

There are resources i can use to decide who were the fastest 25 players in NFL history.......those guys will be the fastest players on this file and everyone else will simply fall in line no acceptions to the rule

Barry Sanders was good.....hell Barry Sanders was GREAT...so was Jim Brown

But having said that Barry Sanders and Jim Brown weren't 99 speed rated players that is what EA gives you...that is not what I'm going to give you.

[jHorns]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

Here's what's going on For the XBOX 360 i'm trying to decide to how to pass the file back and forth between me and another USER who has offered to help me out. Once i get that straighten out then i will start the file...it might just be a situation where i simply just handle everything myself if that doesn't work which is no biggie because I've done much larger roster files than this would be all alone. I think someone is doing a PS3 version so you guys are covered on that end now.... I read in his thread about duplicate players existing....just so that we are on the same page. THERE WILL BE NO DUPLICATE PLAYERS ON THIS FILE.... I don't like that method as I prefer one guy slotted to one team only....these will All-Time rosters which means I' not creating teams based on a season or year. This is like my NCAA Alumni Rosters where i take some of the best players in team history and put them all on one team and let you decide who to start and who will be the backups. These will all be great players but lets get one thing clear they won't all be 90+ overall rated players....if a guy wasn't listed as a burner i'm not going to make him a burner just to inflate his overall rating. I'm not rating guys based on overall's I'm not rating guys base don a overall rating....I'm rating guys based on Tendencies So if i guy didn't have great speed but he had great hands and was terrific route runner and playmaker I.E. Jerry Rice if his speed keeps him from being a 99 overall then so be it. His tendency ratings will allow him to do hi job and be Jerry Rice....the same thing applies to Emmitt Smith he'll be productive without being rated a 90+ speed Ifyour looking for all of your favorite players to be speed demons this fiel won't be for you.....if your looking for guys to be rated 90+ overall because they were great then this file won't be for you..... There are several resources that i can use to determine the 25 best players in NFL history....those guys are the one's you'll most likely see rated in the 90's There are resources i can use to decide who were the fastest 25 players in NFL history.......those guys will be the fastest players on this file and everyone else will simply fall in line no acceptions to the rule Barry Sanders was good.....hell Barry Sanders was GREAT...so was Jim Brown But having said that Barry Sanders and Jim Brown weren't 99 speed rated players that is what EA gives you...that is not what I'm going to give you.

good stuff man, i like the idea on not having any duplicate players, this makes it to where that player can only play for one team. however i think that at least the top 50 on nfl network's list should probably be rated at the best 99 overall rating. i mean the lowest guy on that list might be a 97. 100 players is not much at all considering how many have actually played in the nfl throughout its history. but overall i really like your ideas.

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by jHorns

good stuff man, i like the idea on not having any duplicate players, this makes it to where that player can only play for one team. however i think that at least the top 50 on nfl network's list should probably be rated at the best 99 overall rating. i mean the lowest guy on that list might be a 97. 100 players is not much at all considering how many have actually played in the nfl throughout its history. but overall i really like your ideas.

I know it sounds like i'm going to be short changing some players but that's only because some people are used to EA's ratings scale

If EA scaled back the overall ratings of players or even player speed you'd see still great players look and feel great

Think about it is there really a huge difference between a GREAT PLAYER being a 94 overall as opposed to 99 overall especially if that great player is productive and getting it done based on TENDENCIES as opposed to what his overall rating reflects?

Say for example Dan Marino

If he has great arm strength, outstanding accuarcy and awareness but that only makes him a 92-94 overall because his speed rating isn't high enough to make him a 99 overall does that hurt Marino in the long run?

Another example would be Deacon Jones who stated he only ran about a 4.5 or 4.6 back in his day which was fast at that time. Should i give Deacon Jones 80+ speed just to make his overall a 99?

Or should i use his acceleration to represent his quickness off the ball and then give him outstanding pass rushing tendencies to shed blocks and make him hunt down QB's with a great pursuit rating that offsets his lack of speed

[codyj123_321]

When will these be ready?

[jHorns]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

I know it sounds like i'm going to be short changing some players but that's only because some people are used to EA's ratings scale If EA scaled back the overall ratings of players or even player speed you'd see still great players look and feel great Think about it is there really a huge difference between a GREAT PLAYER being a 94 overall as opposed to 99 overall especially if that great player is productive and getting it done based on TENDENCIES as opposed to what his overall rating reflects? Say for example Dan Marino If he has great arm strength, outstanding accuarcy and awareness but that only makes him a 92-94 overall because his speed rating isn't high enough to make him a 99 overall does that hurt Marino in the long run? Another example would be Deacon Jones who stated he only ran about a 4.5 or 4.6 back in his day which was fast at that time. Should i give Deacon Jones 80+ speed just to make his overall a 99? Or should i use his acceleration to represent his quickness off the ball and then give him outstanding pass rushing tendencies to shed blocks and make him hunt down QB's with a great pursuit rating that offsets his lack of speed

yea i see what youre saying. overalls are a bit overrated, thats kind of like it is in fight night when they started doing overalls but the overall couldnt not tell u at all how good of a fighter he is against another fighter, it was more about the individual ratings then the overall.

[jHorns]

well i made some all time greats and watched them play on cpu vs cpu using your sliders. watching jim brown run just wasnt that exciting honestly. i tried it with the browns at home and they were just stuffing him, i then tried it with the browns as the away team and he was gaining yards but didnt look like jim brown should and i have him at 99 on alot of attributes. i wonder if its because of the slow speed that im playing at. but as far as the visiting team playing better then the home team, i still think that is true in this game as it was with madden 11. also i noticed that for some reason it showed the qb out on the kickoff team but when the ball was actually kicked he wasnt out there. just another stupid bug by ea. i wont even say anything about a patch because they never fix what actually needs to be fixed, the only thing their patches mean is more slider testing to get your game back to the way you like it.

[zac358]

So I have a question. Players who are currently in the NFL Ray Lewis for example. Are you going to edit him and give him his all time ratings or is he going to keep his rating from madden 12. Because he was alot better in his prime then on madden 12 so I was jw.

[jHorns]

Quote: Originally Posted by zac358

So I have a question. Players who are currently in the NFL Ray Lewis for example. Are you going to edit him and give him his all time ratings or is he going to keep his rating from madden 12. Because he was alot better in his prime then on madden 12 so I was jw.

i would assume that people like that he would tweak in order to put them back in their prime years. ray lewis is still awesome even now but not as good as he was in his prime.