OS Poll: Do you agree with the 99 overall ratings for players in Madden?

[FrankieOliver]

Not really an NFL fan but I know about football. NBA all day everyday
I'm not a Patriot's fan, New York Giants follower, but I give credit when credit is due.
Wasn't Tom Brady the MVP last year? Oh I'm sorry the UNANIMOUS MVP. Oh I'm sorry the ONLY UNANIMOUS MVP in the history of the NFL. Well I'm not some big city lawyer but that is an impressive achievement. I think in Madden a 99 rating could be bestowed upon Brady. I think there should be 1 Offensive player rated a 99 (MVP)
And 1 Defensive player rated a 99. Hell EA and Madden could have people vote like they do on the cover.

Next order of business ahem, DirtyJerz32 in NBA 2k11 Jordan is rated 99 on all Bulls Classic teams except for his rookie team 85-86.

[FrankieOliver]

Quote: Originally Posted by FrankieOliver

Not really an NFL fan but I know about football. NBA all day everyday I'm not a Patriot's fan, New York Giants follower, but I give credit when credit is due. Wasn't Tom Brady the MVP last year? Oh I'm sorry the UNANIMOUS MVP. Oh I'm sorry the ONLY UNANIMOUS MVP in the history of the NFL. Well I'm not some big city lawyer but that is an impressive achievement. I think in Madden a 99 rating could be bestowed upon Brady. I think there should be 1 Offensive player rated a 99 (MVP) And 1 Defensive player rated a 99. Hell EA and Madden could have people vote like they do on the cover. Next order of business ahem, DirtyJerz32 in NBA 2k11 Jordan is rated 99 on all Bulls Classic teams except for his rookie team 85-86.

*CORRECTION*
AND 94-95 BULLS.

[DPM19]

I believe 99 ovr should be reserved for the players who are being talked about in Hall of Fame standards. there should also be a limit of five or so a game.

[PlayoffSystemNow]

What players in recent history acually MIGHT deserve a 99 rating if a game was made that year? Here are some examples... Jerry Rice or Joe Montana after Super Bowl 24, Emmit Smith after Super Bowl 28, Barry Sanders after his 2,000 yard season, Brady and Moss after their record breaking season, basically only Hall of Famers after one of their best seasons.

[Capn Cowboy]

Although those guys are some of the best in their positions (and probably some of the best ever), I think that a "99" rating should be achieved over a career, you know, maybe work their way TO a "99".But, what do I know??