Xbox 360: 2009-2010 Roster Project.

[sra9888]

DC, is there any way you could PM me your formulas for creating players. There was an old spreadsheet that I was trying to use, but that failed to give all of the ratings and I felt that it overrated/underrated players too often. There were too many 90+ guys as well as too much of a dropoff for non-starters. It looks like you have a great handle on the rating system and if you have a spreadsheet or formula set I would like to use it to either help you guys create rosters OR to simply use it to create my roster set for either older rosters or just to use to update rosters for this year/next year.

[o0luke0o]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCAllAmerican

I was just about to make a post about them. I should be done with them a few days after the National Championship Game I am not trying to be Hitler here or anything but, I think we need to stick to the same formulas. I have a lot of things that I do when it comes to these rosters that are proven. A lot of credit to 500bloc and work we have done in the past. I still use his formulas to this day. But I will be writing some things up that people need to stick to when creating these rosters because (no disrespect) people that created freshmen last year did a bad job when it came to overrating their talent levels. But I will discuss this. Again sorry if I am coming off as a jerk but I am confident in my knowledge of the 2K Rating System

I agree. I'd rather work for proven formulas instead of rating randomly.

[DC]

Krauser sorry if I came off the wrong way. I didn't mean any disrespect to anyone's rosters. Didn't mean to rub you or anyone else the wrong way.

But as I said, people that did the rosters last year overrated the Freshman severely. I just don't want to run into that issue again, while I didn't think I was knocking anyone's rosters, I apologize

Quote:

Many of your theory are just cookie cutter idea- like all elite players with 99 consistency which are really just done to save time and not to be necessarily accurate. Alot of players with elite stats are not consistency. While you can hail yourself the god of whatever you want. All i see is same know it all attitude you always present.

Actually these things have been confirmed and aren't just ways to save me time Krause.

[o0luke0o]

Krauser everything is cool man. No disrespect was intended, your rosters last year were great.

[dkrause1971]

I hope your rosters turn out well. No hard feelings. OS boards just seem to be so negative and demanding in general i took it the wrong way, when i took a break after arguing with cubfan and looked back at the posts i knew i over reacted.

I wish the mods would step into the ncaa, show, etc forums more and just clean out the posts and posters who really seem to be bring this site down to the lowest common denominator. Instead, it seems anything goes now.

I am not sure i buy the 99 in consistency for all elite players being the right thing to do but i am sure not everyone agreed with things i do. I'll be interested to see how it works out. I have been wrong before. The other ratings ideas mentioned i do think are very good ideas for whats its worth.

[DC]

No hard feelings man. I knew something was up because I have never seen you react like that. So I figured you were having a bad day.

But also know I have a great deal of respect for your work. If it wasn't for you we wouldn't even have anything to base the 08-09 rosters from. So your work is appreciated man

What would you suggest when it comes to the Consistency?

When I say ELITE players, this season the only person I would put there would be probably Blake. Maybe Hansboropugh

I don't know how I feel when it comes to putting someone like Curry on the list considering his game is practically the deep ball and we know nobody that has a game based on the 3 should have a 99 consistency

Thinking about Hansborough

[dkrause1971]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCAllAmerican

No hard feelings man. I knew something was up because I have never seen you react like that. So I figured you were having a bad day. But also know I have a great deal of respect for your work. If it wasn't for you we wouldn't even have anything to base the 08-09 rosters from. So your work is appreciated man What would you suggest when it comes to the Consistency? When I say ELITE players, this season the only person I would put there would be probably Blake. Maybe Hansboropugh I don't know how I feel when it comes to putting someone like Curry on the list considering his game is practically the deep ball and we know nobody that has a game based on the 3 should have a 99 consistency Thinking about Hansborough

If elite is literally like 1-3 people then i could see 99 consistency. I was taking elite to be more like everyone on the all American teams. Curry is a good consistency player but i would think more confidence than 99 consistency. Players like Hansbourgh and Griffin are more 99 consistency to me. Maybe Blair too.

[DC]

I wouldn't put Blair in there just because he is missing some games due to foul trouble.

So yea Tyler and Blake.

I don't think I would ever put a guard on that list though. They are bound to have bad shooting days sooner or later.

[o0luke0o]

DC, I wanted to ask you about incoming recruits. Do you have any formulas I could use to create the freshmen? PM if you do.

[Seryn]

Any updates here? Which roster do you plan to use as a base file?

Just curious is all