First Annual Best Sports Game Of All Time Tournament

[arseniotall]

NFL 2k5 by a mile!

[theaub]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlyGilmore

didn't it have some amazing commentary for the time? i remember one of those hard ball games having Al Michaels doing the play-by-play and doing an incredible job.

Yup...that was Hardball III.

The day a couple years ago when my DOS CPU died was a sad, sad day, since it deleted my awesome stadium with 200 foot fences in LF/RF and a 650 foot fence in CF.

[JonahNYC]

Baseball Stars went further than Earl Weaver Baseball? Something SERIOUSLY wrong here.

[BlyGilmore]

not really Jonah. Baseball Stars was a revolutionary console game that featured many of the elements we take for granted today. for instance it was the first console baseball game to have leagues, trades, keep statistics, create players, create teams, edit players and their attributes and much more.

EW and EWII were great games, don't get me wrong.