[DarkFudge]

While I do enjoy the variety in running animations and overall distinctions in the different player's abilities that All Pro 2K8 brought to the table, there were many things in 2K8 that I still thought were very flawed.

For example, alot of the animations started to get that repetitive, deja vu feeling to certain outcomes on specific plays. For example, every time I would run a certain play, the exact outcome of the results, animations, etc would start to repeat itself in a cycle of either "this" or "that".....rather than seeing completely organic results each time you ran it, based on different players and teams.

A good example would be running a quick out pattern...it was either caught, and then the defender would tackle the player immediately or the defender would diagonally caught across the path and tip the ball while tackling the reciever....It was too many of those 'either'/'or' scenarios like that which would made the game start to feel somewhat on scripted on/off rails at times....at least moreso than Madden that had more opportunity for organic results


Now this is not to say that Madden is superior, because it is far from it...especially with those unnatural and cartoony player models. Madden cant compare to what 2K delivered 2 years ago.

Im hoping Madden 2010 can rectify some of this