[JBH3]

In your opinion who would win this game if these two teams played - now - given age and where they're at in their careers development wise?

2003-04 ALL NBA 1st TEAM
Shaq
Duncan
KG
Kobe
Kidd

2003-04 ALL ROOKIE 1st TEAM
Bosh
Carmelo
Lebron
Wade
Hinrich

The rookie team would be outsized, but the 1st team would be out-athleticised (?). The 1st team is obviously better defensively, but the all-rookie is so nasty on offense between Wade, Melo, Bosh, and Lebron. I think the All-Rook team would run them off the court though. In the halfcourt the All-NBA is beast, but the All-Rook team would annihilate them in transistion.