[Hammerhunker]

Quote: Originally Posted by mgoblue

I personally think that NFL 2k5 is overrated in a similar way to John F. Kennedy, the whole "died before their time" aspect makes people forget their flaws... I suppose the rabid fans kinda turn me off of that game as well. The way some people talk it sounds like if you put the game in your pants it does "magic"... Congrats on winning though!

Not a strong analogy, got the "died before their time" bit. I don't see that as the point. You have to look at the amount of people that still play this game either as their main football game or occasionally. What 2k5 did was great, it has stood up against time. I don't know of many other games that can do that.