Not really, you don't have to look 2K games to like 1 more than the other. CHoops is the best sports game I have ever played and I've voted for it since it was a 14 seed in round 1.
I'm not quite sure what it does for you or this site to label things based on your opinion other than undermining the whole process. I was really hoping I wouldn't ever see the word 'fanboi' here, but I guess the the 2K, EA, and WoW forums met up with Avril Lavigne and decided to become a contributor at OS.