[daflyboys]

Quote: Originally Posted by ehh

Yeah, this is simply a popularity contest at this point. Neither of these games have any business being here, well I guess I could argue for CH2k8. I wouldn't even put NFL2k5 as one of the Top 5 football games ever made but I know there are plenty of die-hards here who keep modding it. Imagine if The Show wasn't so popular and a majority of baseball fans were stuck with a "Madden-like" baseball game, MVP on the PC would have won this contest by a landslide.

You were expecting something other than a popularity contest? As much as I like MVP on the PC, it has its' flaws as well. And remember it was only made great by the modders. So in its' raw form it's still a great baseball game, but.....