Don't forget Willie McGee and Ozzie Smith to go along with Vince Coleman in RBI Baseball, all three were nearly impossible to throw out.
There was also Deion Sanders in one of the versions of Triple Play Baseball, maybe 99. He too was impossible to throw out at second unless you had Ivan Rodriguez (and even he had a 10% chance at best). You could put him at catcher and suffer no ill consequences. In the leagues we would run he would always be a sought after player. We always gave first choice of the Free Agents to the person who had the last pick in the fantasy draft and Deion was always the first choice.
Lets also not forget Jerry Rice in pretty much any video games from Tecmo Super Bowl through the Madden games on the Genesis.