Users Online Now: 2231  |  April 24, 2014
Wiggy's Blog
Informed Speculation: Xbox One and What it Means for Sports Games Stuck
Posted on May 24, 2013 at 08:55 AM.


Now that we know a lot more about the Xbox One, there are certain realities that are setting in for the future of sports games. Without a doubt, there are aspects of the new system worth getting excited about. It'll be awesome to be able to switch between tasks quickly, and the speedy system boot-up and resume features will mean that players will be able to get in and out of games that much faster. I think it's awesome for many reasons, not the least of which is that you can get into a season mode or tournament without all of the cumbersome loading times and menus. It'll certainly be nice to bypass all of that when you wake the system up and get back into your game, and loading times should be better thanks to mandatory installs, faster processors and cloud-powered features.

Just the same, it'll be cool to have the snap feature that will allow for fantasy league users to stay up to date on a given day, and the NFL license and exclusive content is great for those who are looking for that kind of experience. Honestly, even Skype probably has some uses within sports games, as users can have a richer chat experience when they're setting up leagues, conducting fantasy drafts or just playing one-on-one.

I'm also excited about the revised Kinect camera, and I think the improved latency, resolution and voice detection will be awesome for fitness and dance games, and it will help augment games of all types. I can imagine some pretty cool voice technology for football and hockey, and the potential for the Kinect measuring heartbeat, engagement and things of that nature could yield interesting results for games that are going for a certain intensity.

But with all of this good stuff comes some negatives, and these will impact sports games just as much as any other genre. The reasoning behind some of these decisions varies, with certain choices being made to combat piracy and others being made just purely for profit reasons. Either way, it's hard not to be disappointed by a lot of these items listed below.



(1) The Xbox One will not ship with a headset

In a truly baffling move, Microsoft has said that the Xbox One will have no headset bundled in. This means that users will have to either pony up substantial bucks for a Turtle Beach headset (partnership just announced today), or stick with the improved but still less-than-desirable Kinect microphone for in-game chat. I think this is a massive miscalculation on Microsoft's part, especially in light of old headsets not working on the new system.

What possible reason is there to not include a headset and shut out current headsets? This reeks of MS just wanting to offload an expense onto consumers, and it's an indication that the console won't be cheap. They're looking for ways to save a couple of bucks, and they want to get a piece of the audio money pie that Turtle Beach has been enjoying for a while. Smart for business; bad for consumers. Not including a headset with the system emulates the Sony model from this generation, where the PS3 community suffered because you couldn't count on everyone having a headset. This is hugely important for sports games, especially for users in online leagues. Of course, people can go buy a headset, but this is purely a profit move on MS' part.

(2) Used games will not work the same as they do now

Now, this one is definitely some informed speculation, but we all knew there was a reason that EA was getting rid of the online pass system. I had figured that MS was going to bring in their own form of authentication system for each game, and it appears they've done just that. This is obviously to combat lost revenue to used games as well as piracy, but from everything they've said, it seems like they're going too far.

MS has alluded that you will be able to trade games back or something to that effect (possibly even trading licenses to friends), but the fact that you can't lend a game to a friend or family member for them to use is absolute nonsense. The reason Steam is viewed positively is because Valve has leaned completely into digital, with competitive sale pricing, a proper offline mode, gifting of games and free online multiplayer. Microsoft seems to be straddling the line between physical and digital, and I get the feeling that they won't be pricing as competitively as the stuff you see on Steam.

(3) The Xbox One requires some sort of always-online DRM

The details on this feature have been murky as well, but the general consensus seems to be that the Xbox One is meant to function with power all of the time (thanks to its varying power states), and ideally it needs an internet connection all of the time as well. It will allow for some kind of off-line time (currently set at 24 hours), but presumably after that interval, you will have to reconnect with the system in order to use your games and content.

Now, where sports gamers -- and gamers in general -- should be concerned here is not with just one small use case but with all of the possible use cases put together. What if your ISP goes down? What if your local network (router) goes down? What if you want to take a system over to a friend's house where internet isn't going to be easy to hook up? What if you want to take the system to a vacation spot or a hotel? What about people in the military? What about -- and this is the biggest one -- Microsoft's servers going down? There are plenty of legitimate reasons that people might not have a connection for a while, and this type of setup also assumes that Microsoft's servers will never have problems or downtime.

I think it will take just one major title having an issue on launch before MS feels the heat for something like this. What if someone can't play single-player Madden when they get home from the store? That's a problem.




(4) The Xbox One will not allow indies to self-publish

This decision is just mean-spirited to me. It sounds as if MS really wants to curate their store, and frankly, I think they just don't want to have to deal with indie devs as much, especially since some of them can be quite vocal about their grievances.

Honestly, what would be the harm in having self-publishers on the Xbox One marketplace? Microsoft still gets a cut of the sales, even if a game isn't selling like gangbusters. Also, and I'm sure fellow OS staffer Jayson Young will agree, we won't see fun little diversions like Blockey or Avatar Football on the Xbox One. For shame, Microsoft.



(5) The EA exclusive deal helps no one except Microsoft and EA

Obviously, this is a big deal -- pun intended -- for Microsoft and Electronic Arts. It will help steer early adopters of the new systems towards Microsoft's ecosystem, and EA gets a big pile of money. While this is nice if you're lucky enough to own two systems or choose to take part in the Xbox One, it's ultimately just a business move that shuts out content (and potentially even shifts release dates of games) for half of your user base. These kind of partnerships are going to happen, because that's just how business works, but it's nothing for gamers to really be excited about.

Final Thoughts

I am genuinely interested in a lot of features in the Xbox One, and I'm hopeful that there will be some awesome game experiences that aren't just about pushing poly counts and adding new animations. However, the "features" I outlined above give me pause, and I think these factors are a big negative for gamers in general. I hope some of these decisions and policies get revisited, because as it stands, they actually make the ecosystem worse off than it was before.
Comments
# 1 Profit89 @ May 24
I agree. And #5 is the big one imo.

This partnership with EA is a horrible idea. Lately, everything EA touches turns to stone. They make awful business decisions. And this move will hurt Microsoft in the long run. A very bad business decision long term.

It's obvious that they want to stomp out competition. Their attitude towards the indie scene is self-evident. Any indie developer will have to get approval from one of the signed on big publishers like EA. That's a horrible idea. The indie scene is now massive. It's enormous. It cannot be stopped.

A move like this would have been successful in the last generation, but there is simply to much knowledge and information now to be able to pull it off now. We have choices. Look at the enormous growth of Steam/PC Gaming. People now have more choice than ever.

Control is being taken away fro the user. And when that happens people start looking for alternatives. And those alternatives now exist.
 
# 2 wallofhate @ May 24
I was baffled too from alot of the info that was released on the xbox one. I'm definitely gonna wait until the smoke clears to see what comes about worth this. Hopefully Microsoft comes to their senses and remove their arrogance from their business decisions. I love xbox and only purchased the ps3 because of the blu Ray player and I figured next gen I'm gonna be done with ps3 but if it is like this ps4 here I come
 
# 3 CribbsStyle @ May 24
Where has it been announced that the Xbox One will NOT ship with a headset? I can not find that information anywhere.
 
# 4 PH1LLYSFINEST13 @ May 24
Can I use bluetooth headset that I have for my 360 for the XboxOne? Thats my question. A lot of disturbing news from the thing I was sold in on buying about a week ago.
 
# 5 Wiggy @ May 24
Quote:
Where has it been announced that the Xbox One will NOT ship with a headset? I can not find that information anywhere.
http://ca.ign.com/articles/2013/05/2...aming-headsets

Here's the news about the chat port being proprietary and not supporting old headsets.

https://www.gameinformer.com/b/featu...c-whitten.aspx

Here's the confirmation about no headsets. While Whitten didn't say iron-clad "there will be no headset packed in," he basically steered the question towards the Kinect and the overall headset strategy. I take this as a confirmation that there won't be one included.

It certainly doesn't look like you can use bluetooth, but I can see that there probably will be an "official" MS headset still, just sold separately. I could also see them cramming one in the console at the last minute, but right now, it seems like they won't.
 
# 6 JoedicyMichael @ Jun 1
Im so glad you shared this info! Real enlightening info here
 
Wiggy
27
Wiggy's Blog Categories
Wiggy's Xbox 360 Gamercard
Wiggy's Friends
Recent Visitors
The last 10 visitor(s) to this Arena were:

Wiggy's Arena has had 306,432 visits